Indiana Motorist Appeals Conviction in Fatal Crash
Alyssa Shepherd’s attorney says that although the crash is a “heart-wrenching tragedy, we believe it is still just an accident and not a crime.”
Sadiah Thompson・Assistant Editor
January 28, 2020
Alyssa Shepherd of Indiana has appealed her conviction in the fatal crash that killed three students and injured another as they were trying to board their school bus. Photo courtesy Indiana State Police
2 min to read
Alyssa Shepherd of Indiana has appealed her conviction in the fatal crash that killed three students and injured another as they were trying to board their school bus. Photo courtesy Indiana State Police
ROCHESTER, Ind. — The motorist who was convicted in a crash that killed three students and injured another as they were trying to board a school bus is appealing her conviction.
As School Bus Fleet previously reported, a judge sentenced Alyssa Shepherd, 25, in December to four years in prison for the Oct. 30, 2018, crash that killed 6-year-old twins Xzavier and Mason Ingle and their sister, 9-year-old Alivia Stahl, and seriously injured another student. She was convicted in October by a jury of three counts of reckless homicide, a felony count of criminal recklessness, and a misdemeanor count for passing a school bus and causing injury when the stop arm is extended.
A notice of appeal was filed on Jan. 17 with the Indiana Court of Appeals on behalf of Shepherd, according to WRTV. Stacy Uliana, the attorney representing Shepherd, said in an email to the news source on Tuesday that “we are appealing because although the accident is a heart-wrenching tragedy, we believe it is still just an accident and not a crime.” She also said that a brief outlining arguments in her client’s appeal will not be filed for months.
Shepherd, who was also sentenced to three years of house arrest, three years of probation, and a 10-year driver’s license suspension, reportedly told investigators during a probable cause hearing for the crash that she didn’t see the bus or the students until it was too late to stop. The bus apparently had its lights flashing and stop arm extended at the time.
Several legislative measures have been introduced as a result of the crash, including Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb’s school bus safety law that was signed in May to increase penalties for violating a stop arm. More recently, on Jan. 6, Sen. Ron Alting introduced a bill amendment that would let police seize the vehicle of a motorist who illegally passes a stopped school bus. The legislation followed an announcement of a special school bus stop safety patrol program’s results, which included 2,500 citations, of which 453 were for stop-arm violators.
Driver shortages, safety expectations, and staffing limits define student transportation in 2026. New survey data shows how fleet leaders are responding.
The federal agency's report asks NHTSA to require all new school buses to be equipped with vehicle-integrated alcohol detection systems and passenger lap-shoulder belts.
Student transportation teams are being asked to do more with less, facing driver shortages, rising costs, and increasing safety expectations. This report uncovers how fleets are adapting, where technology is making the biggest impact, and why student ridership tracking is emerging as a top priority. Download the report to explore the key trends shaping 2026 and what they mean for your operation.
A Carroll County accident claimed the lives of two students and injured over a dozen others on a March 27 field trip for eighth graders at Clarksville-Montgomery County. A preliminary report adds new information to the story.
From driver shortage solutions in Tennessee and rural connectivity debates in Utah to new safety laws in Wisconsin and ongoing electric bus mandate discussions in New York and Connecticut, here’s the latest in school bus legislation across the U.S.
Waymo’s self-driving vehicles are under fire again after repeated school bus passing violations, raising questions about safety, remote operators, and regulation.
Distracted driving continues to pose serious risks in school zones, with new data and driver insights highlighting ongoing concerns and potential solutions to improve student and roadway safety.
A former airline pilot has stepped into a new role at the independent federal agency, but where does he stand on issues like seat belts on school buses? Here’s what he’s said.
Two recent close calls at railroad crossings, a train clipping a bus and a rear-end crash, highlight why vigilance and training still matter. Here’s what happened and what to tell your own drivers.
The federal agency's proposed rulemaking would eliminate the requirement for school buses to come to a complete stop at railroad crossings if the warning device is not activated. The goal: to improve traffic flow and save costs. With new data released, public comment is open through April 27, 2026.
