Motorist in Fatal Crash Reportedly Says She Didn’t See School Bus

Nicole Schlosser
Posted on November 2, 2018
The Indiana driver who allegedly passed a school bus and hit and killed three students told investigators that she didn’t see the bus (shown here) or the students until it was too late. Photo courtesy Indiana State Police
The Indiana driver who allegedly passed a school bus and hit and killed three students told investigators that she didn’t see the bus (shown here) or the students until it was too late. Photo courtesy Indiana State Police

ROCHESTER, Ind. — The motorist who was allegedly involved in a fatal school bus passing incident on Tuesday reportedly told investigators that she didn’t see the bus or the students until it was too late to stop.

As SBF previously reported, Alyssa Shepherd is accused of illegally passing a school bus, killing three students and seriously injuring one other student. She was arrested on Tuesday and received three felony charges for reckless homicide and a misdemeanor count for passing a school bus with the stop arm extended, causing injury.

Michelle Jumper, a detective for the Indiana State Police, interviewed Shepherd; Robert Reid, school bus driver for Tippecanoe Valley School Corp.; and a witness, according to Indianapolis Star. (The court provided the newspaper on Thursday with audio recording of the probable cause hearing in Fulton County Court on Tuesday.) In that hearing, Jumper testified that Shepherd said she drove around a corner and saw "something [that was] big and had lights," Jumper said. “She did not recognize it in any way as a school bus."

Jumper also said that Shepherd had three children in the back seat of her car, had dropped off her husband at work at about 7:05 a.m., and was driving to her mother’s home in the Rochester area to drop off her brother when she drove around the bend in the road, according to the newspaper.

A witness told Jumper that she was driving a vehicle behind Shepherd’s through the bend on State Road 25, that she and Shepherd were traveling at 45 miles per hour, and that she slowed down when she saw the school bus and its flashing lights, which she said were clearly visible, Jumper testified. Jumper also said that the witness told her that “the truck's headlights illuminated the children as they were crossing the road and she said she started to freak out as she realized 'I'm slowing down, but that truck in front of me is not slowing,'" Indianapolis Star reports.

Reid, the school bus driver, told Jumper that he stopped at the same place where he always picks up the students, and that he told investigators that he saw headlights coming from around the bend in the road, but they were far away and he had time to slow down, so he waved to the students to cross the road. He also said, Jumper testified, that he honked the horn when it was apparent that the truck wasn’t going to stop, according to the newspaper.

Meanwhile, Blaine Conley, superintendent for Tippecanoe Valley School Corp., posted a statement on the district’s Facebook page that said that the district relocated the bus stop where the incident occurred as of Thursday. He also said in the statement that he is establishing a transportation safety review committee to examine all of the district’s bus stop locations “to ensure our children are transported safely.”

Related Topics: fatalities, Indiana, lighting, school bus crash, stop-arm running/illegal passing

Nicole Schlosser Executive Editor
Comments ( 15 )
  • Laura Clark

     | about 12 months ago

    Gross negligence- reckless disregard of a legal duty and of the consequences to another party. Coming up and over a hill on a curve in the dark at any speed and to SEE headlights w/flashing Red lights says DANGER! Not only to myself my children or My family ,my friends or my animals in MY car PLUS potential damage to My vehicle . Brain alert!!!CAUTION HAZARD WARNING especially w/farm equipment HUGE Giant Blades thats hacking up the Maize.Giant tubes spitting it out into huge semi trucks.Tires that are Bigger than my truck! Babies on Board! Why would I not slow down for every one I love so precious and dear to me? Why take a chance staring at freaking headlights like a deer. OMG!!! Rather than slow down so I dont hit the damb thing or it me "trying" to figure out ,what is it? WHY WHY WHY??? One other question besides the obvious -why in the hell would that bus stop twice for 12 trailers??? The district seems they had babies street walking in the dark to save time in the first place.So 2 stops seems a little far fetched. There are two entrances to the park. I made a round trip over 120miles too see if I could see what road type Alyssa was possibly faced with .If I could maybe feel sympathy. for her or would I have been so gross myself ???. She didnt stop or hug nothing till 200ft. Past the bus -

  • See all comments
More Stories
Mobile County (Ala.) Public Schools bus driver Kimberleigh Welch passed away on Thursday after another vehicle hit her bus, causing it to overturn. Photo courtesy Mobile County Public Schools

Alabama School Bus Driver Dies After Bus Overturns

Kimberleigh Welch is traveling along the highway when another vehicle hits her bus, causing it to overturn. She is taken to the hospital where she succumbs to her injuries. No one else was on board at the time.

Michigan City (Ind). Area Schools’ transportation department recently recreated The Supremes’ famous “Stop in the Name of Love” — urging motorists to think twice before illegally passing a stopped school bus. Photo courtesy Michigan City Area Schools

School Bus Safety Ramps Up Amid Increased Stop-Arm Running Incidents

Stop-arm cameras, partnerships with law enforcement for increased traffic patrol, and public safety campaigns are just some of the measures school districts are taking to ensure the yellow bus is the safest mode of transportation for students. Lawmakers are also introducing several federal and state safety bills.

Greenville County (S.C.) Schools aide Linda (shown left) and bus driver Carlos spotted a boy who had gone missing the night before and brought him to safety. Photo courtesy Greenville County Schools

School Bus Driver, Aide Locate Missing Boy

Bus driver Carlos and aide Linda of South Carolina are driving on their morning route when they spot a boy who had gone missing the night before. They convince him to board the bus and take him to safety.


Child Found Driving School Bus Across Town

The Louisiana 10-year-old drives the bus from a local high school after it was apparently unlocked and the keys were left inside, officials say. The child is taken into custody.

NHTSA has issued an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on a requirement for a seat belt use warning system for rear seats. File photo

NHTSA Seeks Comment on Seat Belt Use Warning System in Rear Seats

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration issues an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on a requirement for a seat belt use warning system for rear seats. In particular, the agency seeks comment on a requirement for high-occupancy vehicles, including 15-passenger vans and school buses.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!