Related: School Bus Safety Ramps Up Amid Increased Stop-Arm Running Incidents
Indiana Motorist Appeals Conviction in Fatal Crash
Alyssa Shepherd’s attorney says that although the crash is a “heart-wrenching tragedy, we believe it is still just an accident and not a crime.”

Alyssa Shepherd of Indiana has appealed her conviction in the fatal crash that killed three students and injured another as they were trying to board their school bus. Photo courtesy Indiana State Police

ROCHESTER, Ind. — The motorist who was convicted in a crash that killed three students and injured another as they were trying to board a school bus is appealing her conviction.
As School Bus Fleet previously reported, a judge sentenced Alyssa Shepherd, 25, in December to four years in prison for the Oct. 30, 2018, crash that killed 6-year-old twins Xzavier and Mason Ingle and their sister, 9-year-old Alivia Stahl, and seriously injured another student. She was convicted in October by a jury of three counts of reckless homicide, a felony count of criminal recklessness, and a misdemeanor count for passing a school bus and causing injury when the stop arm is extended.
A notice of appeal was filed on Jan. 17 with the Indiana Court of Appeals on behalf of Shepherd, according to WRTV. Stacy Uliana, the attorney representing Shepherd, said in an email to the news source on Tuesday that “we are appealing because although the accident is a heart-wrenching tragedy, we believe it is still just an accident and not a crime.” She also said that a brief outlining arguments in her client’s appeal will not be filed for months.
Shepherd, who was also sentenced to three years of house arrest, three years of probation, and a 10-year driver’s license suspension, reportedly told investigators during a probable cause hearing for the crash that she didn’t see the bus or the students until it was too late to stop. The bus apparently had its lights flashing and stop arm extended at the time.
Several legislative measures have been introduced as a result of the crash, including Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb’s school bus safety law that was signed in May to increase penalties for violating a stop arm. More recently, on Jan. 6, Sen. Ron Alting introduced a bill amendment that would let police seize the vehicle of a motorist who illegally passes a stopped school bus. The legislation followed an announcement of a special school bus stop safety patrol program’s results, which included 2,500 citations, of which 453 were for stop-arm violators.
More Safety

Pro-Vision Launches AI-Powered 360° Camera System
The new Birdseye camera delivers real-time AI-based pedestrian and vehicle detections, full visibility around the bus, and telematics integrations.
Read More →
N.Y. & N.J. Coalitions Call for Modernized Transportation for Vulnerable Students
New statewide coalitions in New York and New Jersey are urging lawmakers to expand student transportation options for vulnerable students amid ongoing driver shortages.
Read More →
America Has a School Bus Passing Problem — and Distraction Is Making It Worse
Illegal school bus passing remains a major safety threat as distracted driving rises. This op-ed explores why awareness, enforcement, and stop-arm cameras matter more than ever.
Read More →
School Bus Laws to Watch: New York Delays EV Mandate
Plus, federal lawmakers seek new funding for school bus safety as states weigh stop-arm enforcement, disability protections, and education spending.
Read More →
The Essential Handbook for Safe Alternative Student Transportation
Your district's "exception riders" — students with IEPs, those experiencing homelessness, foster care youth — deserve more than a middleman solution. This handbook breaks down exactly what to look for in a supplemental transportation partner: from driver vetting and regulatory compliance to proactive safety technology. Because getting a ride isn't the same as getting a safe one.
Read More →
Operation STEER Brings Emergency Response Training to North Texas
Prosper ISD hosted the third annual training for transportation professionals across 67 districts to learn how to respond to emergencies, such as rollovers and evacuations, and proper use of safety equipment.
Read More →
Florida District Relaunches BusPatrol School Bus Camera Program With New Safeguards
After being suspended over due process concerns, Miami-Dade schools and law enforcement are restarting the AI-powered stop-arm camera program with new oversight.
Read More →
School Bus Laws To Watch: Seat Belt Bills, Funding Fights & EV Changes
From national bills on seat belts and driver oversight to driver awareness campaigns referencing “Finn’s Rule” and ongoing transportation funding debates in Alaska, here’s the latest in school bus legislation across the U.S.
Read More →
9-Year-Old Boy Killed by School Bus at Busy Brooklyn Intersection
A Williamsburg community is mourning after a child was fatally struck by a private yeshiva bus, prompting calls for urgent safety improvements at the high-traffic crossing.
Read More →
Does Reliable School Transportation Boost Attendance? EverDriven’s Data Says Yes
The new data shows 99.99% incident-free trips and strong on-time performance, reinforcing how dependable transportation, especially for vulnerable student populations, can help districts combat chronic absenteeism.
Read More →
