School Bus Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NSTA Advocacy in Action — The Beginnings of Real Regulatory Reform

Two initiatives that the National School Transportation Association has worked extensively to modify or defeat over the past few years have recently been withdrawn by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.

by Ronna Weber
August 7, 2017
NSTA Advocacy in Action  — The Beginnings of Real Regulatory Reform

 

3 min to read


Regulatory reform is one of President Trump’s highest priorities, and several comprehensive governmentwide efforts are underway to work toward the goals of reducing regulations and creating hurdles for any new regulations to be proposed.

At the U.S. Department of Transportation, two initiatives that the National School Transportation Association (NSTA) has worked extensively to modify or defeat over the past few years have recently been withdrawn by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA).

First, the advance notice of proposed rulemaking on financial responsibility issued by FMCSA in November 2014 was withdrawn on June 5, 2017. The proposal would have had a significant and detrimental effect on the school transportation industry. FMCSA was asking for data in an effort to consider significantly increasing the federally required insurance minimums.

Currently, passenger carriers are required to carry a minimum of $5 million per vehicle in insurance, but many carriers carry more than the minimum. Despite there being no data indicating current minimum requirements were insufficient, by all reports FMCSA was considering raising minimum limits to at least $20 million and indexing them to the medical consumer price index.

This level of increase would have put many contractors out of business. NSTA made overturning this effort a top priority, making the issue the central focus of our 2015 Capitol Hill Bus-In in Washington, D.C. During the event, our members spent a day educating their elected officials on the issue and our concerns.

We also worked with congressional leaders on legislation to stop the financial responsibility proposal. Ultimately, NSTA was successful in securing language in the FAST Act in 2015 to prevent FMCSA from raising current minimums without significant comprehensive studies of the sufficiency of current limits. NSTA included withdrawal of FMCSA’s proposal in our priorities to President Trump’s transition team.

Second, FMCSA withdrew its proposal on safety fitness determination on March 23, 2017. This proposal would have radically changed the safety determination rating system from that of “satisfactory,” “conditional,” and “unfit” to one of either “unfit” or no rating.

NSTA had great concerns with this proposal. First, as an industry, our top priority is safety. To shift from a positive focus of promoting safety to a negative focus of only recognizing those who are unsafe is counterintuitive. In addition, the rating system is extremely confusing for the traveling public, who would rely on the ratings when looking to secure transportation services.

Ronna Weber is the former executive director of the National School Transportation Association.

Perhaps most important, NSTA objected to a new safety fitness determination system being built on top of the flawed Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) system that Congress had just directed the agency to significantly reform in the FAST Act. The FAST Act required a study by the National Academy of Sciences as an initial first step to CSA reform.

At this writing, that study is expected to be sent to Congress at the end of June. FMCSA will have six months to develop a plan to address the recommendations of the study.

Ad Loading...


NSTA’s highest legislative priority in 2016 was to secure legislative language to prevent the safety fitness proposal from being finalized until all CSA reforms mandated by the FAST Act are completed, and this language was included in the fiscal year 2017 House transportation appropriations bill.

NSTA and a coalition of truck and passenger industry groups wrote to Secretary of Transportation Elaine Chao in February asking for the safety fitness proposal to be withdrawn, which was cited as a determinative issue in her statement on the withdrawal.

NSTA is very appreciative of the Trump administration’s action on both of these troubling rulemaking proposals. NSTA supports reasonable regulation when it is based on data and science, when there is evidence of a significant safety problem, and when the new regulation actually addresses the issue and improves safety.

NSTA hopes other pending rulemakings will also be withdrawn in coming months, and we support the administration’s efforts to pursue comprehensive regulatory reform across all agencies.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

School Bus Fleet graphic announcing Reliant Transportation’s acquisition of Safe-Way Bus and Safe-Way Wisconsin, featuring a large group of school transportation employees waving in front of yellow school buses.
Management•by Staff and News Reports•November 12, 2026

Reliant Transportation to Acquire Safe-Way Bus, Expand Midwest Operations

The Minnesota and Wisconsin-based school and charter service operator adds 160 buses to Reliant's fleet as the company continues its expansion.

Read More →
School Bus Fleet graphic reading “Inspiring Students and School Bus Drivers in Michigan,” featuring Dr. Nathanial Hearne speaking with attendees at Oakland Schools’ October 2026 transportation professional development event.
Management•by Amanda Huggett•November 12, 2026

Michigan ISD Brings Students, School Bus Staff Together for Leadership Training

Oakland Schools is expanding its transportation staff training to include students, designed to build mutual respect and stronger relationships between both.

Read More →
Mount Rushmore featuring the carved faces of four U.S. presidents, with the headline “Who’s on Your Mount Rushmore?” and the School Bus Fleet logo, illustrating the lasting influence of leadership and mentorship.
Management•November 11, 2026

Four Lessons Learned from My Own ‘Mount Rushmore’ of Leaders

What makes a great leader? Shannon Barnett shares what he's learned from influential mentors and why leaders should seek wisdom and pass it on.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
School Bus Fleet’s October 2026 “Changing Lanes” personnel roundup graphic features headshots of six industry professionals from Catalyst Mobility, Netradyne, School Bus Logistics, Verra Mobility, and Zonar.
Management•by Amanda Huggett•November 9, 2026

Changing Lanes: Catalyst Mobility, Netradyne, School Bus Logistics, Verra Mobility, Zonar

Get the rundown on who's been hired, promoted, and appointed to leadership positions at school transportation nonprofits, advisory companies, and tech providers.

Read More →
Promotional graphic announcing nominations for School Bus Fleet’s 2027 Administrator of the Year Award, with the award logo, a magazine cover featuring 2026 winner Kathy Calkins, and a Jan. 8, 2027, nomination deadline.
Management•by Amanda Huggett•November 9, 2026

2027 School Bus Fleet Administrator of the Year: Nominations Now Open

Know a state or district-level transportation director who inspires others, leads by example, and goes above and beyond? Tell us about them for their chance to be recognized in this School Bus Fleet award!

Read More →
School Bus Fleet graphic featuring Bill Pepping of CharterUP in a suit and tie, alongside the headline “Five Questions with Bill Pepping” and the CharterUP and School Bus Fleet logos.
Management•by Elora Haynes•October 30, 2026

5 Questions: How CharterUP Brought a Marketplace to Student Transportation

What does it take to bring a transportation marketplace into K-12? Hear firsthand what CharterUP has learned about the unique needs of schools and bus operators.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
School Bus Fleet graphic featuring the EverDriven logo and a laptop displaying the TripCentral trip tracking dashboard, with the headline “EverDriven Opens TripCentral Management Hub.”
Management•by Elora Haynes•October 29, 2026

EverDriven Expands TripCentral Transportation Management Platform to All Partner Districts

The platform provides school districts with real-time trip tracking, student transportation scheduling tools, and pickup and drop-off management capabilities.

Read More →
School Bus Fleet's 2026 School District Transportation Survey graphic features a smiling school bus driver leaning out of a yellow bus beside its extended stop arm, with the survey title and publication logo.
Management•Cover Story•by Amanda Huggett•October 28, 2026

6 School Transportation Trends to Watch: 2026 District Survey Results

School bus buying is up, fuel choices are shifting, and driver shortages persist. This and more in the latest K-12 public school survey, plus the largest fleets in the U.S.

Read More →
Yellow school buses lined up outside a school building, with the lead bus's stop arm extended. Overlay text reads “Top 100 District Fleets in 2026” with the School Bus Fleet logo.
Management•by Amanda Huggett•October 28, 2026

The 100 Largest School Bus Fleets in America: 2026 Rankings

Which public K-12 school districts are the largest in the nation in terms of bus fleet size? Here are the new standings of the top 100 district fleets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Blue graphic featuring the headline “EverDriven’s New Diesel Savings Calculator” and the School Bus Fleet logo over a background of diesel fuel pricing signs, with a calculator icon.
Management•by News/Media Release•October 22, 2026

EverDriven Launches Route Consolidation Calculator to Estimate Diesel Savings

As diesel prices hit record highs, the largest alternative transportation provider says a 10% route consolidation could save a 120-route district more than $78,000 a year in fuel alone.

Read More →