SBF 70 years logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NSTA Advocacy in Action — How the Balance of Power Protects Our Industry

In the heavily regulated school transportation industry, it often feels like the governmental agencies have all the power. However, the legislative and judicial branches of government provide options for checks and balances.

by Ronna Weber
July 18, 2016
NSTA Advocacy in Action  — How the Balance of Power Protects Our Industry

The legislative and judicial branches of government provide options for checks and balances in the heavily regulated school transportation industry.

3 min to read


The legislative and judicial branches of government provide options for checks and balances in the heavily regulated school transportation industry.

In the heavily regulated school transportation industry, it often feels like the governmental agencies have all the power.

As we should all remember from our civics classes, however, our Founding Fathers had great forethought to ensure that each of the three branches of the federal government have equal powers, and that they each have checks and balances on the other branches so that no one branch has too much power.

So what can the legislative branch (Congress) or the judicial branch (federal court) do when it seems like the executive branch (the president and the agencies) is wielding too much power? In short, there is a lot they can do.

The legislative branch has many options at its disposal. Constituents and the industry bring issues of concern to members of Congress, which prompts a member to become engaged, but members also proactively engage on issues by themselves.

For example, a member of Congress can write a letter to the head of an agency in an effort to seek clarification or additional information on an issue of concern. This is helpful and effective because Congress has oversight responsibility over agencies and the agency has to respond to the letter in writing.

If the member is on a committee of jurisdiction, questions can be asked at relevant hearings about the issue. If the issue is large enough and the member of Congress is either senior enough or has enough support from the committee leadership, a hearing can be called to explore the issue more fully.

Members of Congress can also seek legislation as stand-alone bills or, with enough support, they can seek to add a provision into a bill that is likely headed for a vote. Policy issues can be addressed in either authorization bills or appropriations bills.

Our Founding Fathers had great forethought to ensure that each of the three branches of the federal government have equal powers, and that they each have checks and balances on the other branches so that no one branch has too much power.
Ad Loading...

A very short provision ensuring that an agency may not use funds to promulgate a rulemaking (or not use operating funds to advance an issue) unless it meets certain criteria is sometimes enough to delay or stop regulatory action by an agency. NSTA has been successful in achieving legislation to delay and stop adverse regulatory actions relating to issues of obstructive sleep apnea, minimum insurance increases, and reform of the Compliance, Safety, Accountability program, just to name a few.

Ronna Weber is executive director of the National School Transportation Association.

The judicial branch is an option for the industry as well because any party can bring suit in federal court against a federal agency on a regulatory proceeding believed to be unjustified. This is generally an option pursued when all others fail. It is not a quick or inexpensive solution, but it can be effective with the benefit of time and resources to endure what may be a lengthy court battle.

Is the industry out of options if an agency manages to issue a Final Rule before Congress or the courts are able to stop it? In short, no. Affected stakeholders can petition the agency for reconsideration.

There is also the Congressional Review Act, passed by Congress several years ago. This legislation allows Congress to overturn a Final Rule within very specific parameters. The law requires enough support within Congress, and action must occur within a very short window after issuance of a Final Rule. This option was used successfully to overturn the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s ergonomics rule several years ago.

As another option, lawsuits can be filed.

Finally, a new administration can overturn regulatory actions taken by the previous administration — which often happens during a change in the party of the president.

The bottom line is that it is incumbent on the industry to know and exercise its best available options when necessary.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

The Route thumbnail with school bus fleet logo
SponsoredMarch 19, 2026

All About Cooperative Purchasing: A Guide for School Transportation Pros

Stop bidding everything and try a simpler way. Here's how cooperative purchasing can streamline purchases while maintaining compliance. Sourcewell breaks down the process in this episode of The Route, sponsored by IC Bus.

Read More →
Yellow school bus on road with “Company Update” graphic and EverDriven logo announcing school bus routing services
Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 19, 2026

EverDriven Launches New School Bus Routing Services

The alternative transportation company expands its services to traditional yellow buses with the launch of a new division focused on helping school districts optimize their routes.

Read More →
Joshua Roberts of First Student Inc. recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, shown in a headshot with the School Bus Fleet Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Joshua Roberts of First Student

Roberts, 35, serves as the lead IT application engineer for vehicle electrification at First Student, where he helps shape scalable, real-world EV infrastructure to support student transportation.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Quavion Swazer of Puyallup School District recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, pictured in a headshot with the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Quavion Swazer of Puyallup School District

Swazer, 29, serves as director of transportation at Puyallup School District, where he champions student wellbeing and inspires the next generation of industry leaders.

Read More →
Katia Dubas of IMMI recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, shown in a headshot alongside the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Katia Dubas of IMMI

Dubas, 38, serves as sales manager and safety advocate at IMMI, where she advances school bus occupant protection through industry education, OEM collaboration, and proactive safety policy efforts.

Read More →
Eric Kramlick of TransPar Group recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, shown in a headshot alongside the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Amanda HuggettMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Eric Kramlick of TransPar

Kramlick, 30, runs operations for TransPar in Hawaii, where he also showed dedication while helping Maui recover from the recent wildfires.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Jonquez Moore of Little Elm ISD recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, shown in a headshot with the School Bus Fleet Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Amanda HuggettMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Jonquez Moore of Little Elm ISD

Moore, 32, grew up around the school bus, leading him to the classroom and eventually inspiring high-performing teams while bringing operations in house (twice).

Read More →
Joshua Baran of Odyssey Charter School recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, pictured in a headshot next to the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Joshua Baran of Odyssey Charter School

Baran, 38, serves as transportation supervisor at Odyssey Charter School in Delaware, where he leads daily operations with a focus on safety and professional growth.

Read More →
Tyler Maybee of Denver Public Schools recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, shown in a headshot with the U.S. Capitol in the background and the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Tyler Maybee of Denver Public Schools

Maybee, 36, leads transportation operations for Denver Public Schools, where he is advancing equity, efficiency, and cross-department collaboration to improve student access.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Lexi Higgins of Truckers Against Trafficking recognized as a 2026 School Bus Fleet Trailblazers winner, pictured in a headshot with the Trailblazers award graphic.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 18, 2026

2026 Trailblazer: Lexi Higgins of TAT

Higgins, 38, serves as director of industry engagement at TAT (Truckers Against Trafficking), where she equips school transportation professionals with the tools to recognize and report human trafficking.

Read More →