SBF 70 years logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NAPT News & Views — The School Transportation Marketplace Is Changing, Quickly

With many districts expanding walking distances as a cost-savings measure, it’s time we come to grips with the reality that if no yellow bus is available, someone else will fill the void.

by Mike Martin
August 7, 2017
NAPT News & Views — The School Transportation Marketplace Is Changing, Quickly

Photo courtesy HopSkipDrive

4 min to read


Photo courtesy HopSkipDrive

There’s a lot of creative, innovative thinking going on in the world, a sign of the fast-moving, technology-driven time we live in, which means most of us have to work harder than ever just to keep pace these days.

I discussed this in a previous article (see August 2015 issue, pg. 38), referring to societal trends that are potential “market disrupters” for us professionally, not to be dismissed, but anticipated and contemplated so we can have a role in shaping our future rather than reacting.

I specifically mentioned how the taxicab business was stunned by Uber and similar services that are redefining mobility in many cities, pointing out the direct potential impact to our industry. Chicago and Detroit, for example, have for at least a decade been using taxis to provide transportation for special-needs students.

Well, the story continues to unfold.

Research released recently by University of California Santa Barbara professor Michael Gottfried looked at U.S. Department of Education data from the 2010-11 school year and found that school bus ridership reduces chronic absenteeism by about 2%.

While this gap may seem small, the actual impact could be significant — it is estimated that some 5 million to 7.5 million children in grades K-12 miss a month or more of school every year.

The study should provide food for serious thought in school districts that are considering cutting or reducing bus service as a cost-savings step.

Given this overlay, it should come as no surprise that new thinking is coming to the fore for discussion. The July issue of Reason had an interesting article by Tyler Koteskey called “Uber, But for School Buses.” Koteskey poses the question, “Could ride-sharing become a widespread replacement for traditional modes of school transportation?”

Mike Martin is executive director of NAPT.

He cites Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’ praise for Denver’s school district providing transportation to underserved students attending public and charter schools. Called “Success Express,” it transports students to schools outside their residential assignments, helping them have more choices in schools to attend.

The article cites an Urban Institute report that found that even in cities with the most educational choice (including Denver), there are gaps in transportation infrastructure that cause programs like Success Express to run into problems coordinating with education and transportation officials, and some school districts are reluctant to let their resources benefit schools of choice. Koteskey points to ride-sharing services as a possible solution for parents.

“Startups like HopSkipDrive in Los Angeles, Zum in San Francisco, and Zemcar in Boston already cater to busy parents who need someone to bring their kids to and from school and other activities,” Koteskey writes. “These companies put a premium on safety and trust, typically hiring drivers who have experience working with kids and subjecting them to extensive background checks.”

Stepping aside from the broader discussion of school choice, what about children who need transportation to their assigned public school but are outside the service area for a yellow school bus? These parents currently have no choice but to carpool, drive children themselves, or let their children walk or ride bicycles to school. I’d bet they would be very receptive to Uber and similar services.

And, with many districts expanding walking distances as a cost-savings measure, it’s time we come to grips with the reality that if no yellow bus is available, someone else will fill the void. Unfortunately, the reality is that we as school transportation leaders don’t usually have much, if any, control over these decisions. Yes, we can make the compelling safety and efficiency arguments. But funding is funding, and when there’s not enough to go around, then alternate solutions are going to arise — especially when it comes to access for school choice.

“The conversation no longer needs to be centered on cities fixing the problem from the top down by buying and operating more school buses,” Koteskey writes. “Why not give families the option to use a portion of their students’ individual education funding to take advantage of market-based transportation alternatives?”

This marketplace conversation should serve as a strong reminder that it is time to become better informed about the alternatives to traditional school transportation and get engaged in the conversation.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

Promotional image of Zonar's Bus Suite platform displayed on a desktop monitor, tablet, and smartphone, showcasing dashboards for ridership analytics, route management, GPS tracking, and real-time student transportation operations.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseJuly 10, 2026

Zonar Launches Reimagined Bus Suite Web Portal

Can one platform replace your transportation software stack? Zonar says its new Bus Suite unifies routing, dispatch, field trips, GPS, and parent communication.

Read More →
Three award winners pose with their awards.
Managementby Elora HaynesJuly 9, 2026

Indiana Association Announces 2026 Award Winners

See who earned top honors at the 2026 School Transportation Association of Indiana conference, recognizing excellence in school transportation statewide.

Read More →
Graphic announcing an acquisition in the school transportation industry, featuring the Student Transportation of America (STA) and Tremblay's Bus Company logos over a background of parked yellow school buses, with the headline "Acquisition News" and School Bus Fleet branding.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseJuly 8, 2026

Student Transportation of America Acquires Massachusetts Contractor

Tremblay’s Bus Company and its 400-bus fleet joins the STA family of brands as the company grows its presence across the Northeast U.S.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Collage of winners receiving awards during the 61st Annual Michigan Association for Pupil Transportation (MAPT) Conference, featuring recipients posing on stage with engraved wooden plaques and MAPT branding.
Managementby Amanda HuggettJuly 7, 2026

Michigan Association Announces 2026 Award Winners

See who earned top honors at the 2026 Michigan Association for Pupil Transportation conference, recognizing excellence in school transportation statewide.

Read More →
Thumbnail for a School Bus Fleet video featuring MAPT Executive Director Katrina Morris standing with her arms open in front of a blurred trade show floor at the 61st Annual Michigan Association for Pupil Transportation (MAPT) Conference. A yellow outline of the state of Michigan and the text "MAPT 61st Annual Conference" appear beside her, with the School Bus Fleet logo in the lower-right corner.
Managementby Amanda HuggettJuly 7, 2026

Inside MAPT 2026: Michigan’s School Transportation Community Connects at Boyne Mountain

Check out highlights from the 2026 MAPT Summer Conference, where over 300 transportation pros gathered for training, networking, awards, and trade show.

Read More →
A Durham School Services bus with its stop arm extended.

Summit School Services to Complete Fleetwide Samsara Technology Rollout

The company said outfitting its entire fleet with AI-powered safety and fleet management technology will strengthen student safety and operational efficiency across its local brands.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A black and white image of older school buses lined up with text reading "Why the School Bus May Be America's Most Overlooked Icon."
Managementby Elora HaynesJuly 1, 2026

Why the School Bus May Be America's Most Overlooked Icon

Every day, millions of students climb aboard. But few realize the yellow school bus has helped transform education, connect communities, and come to symbolize civic responsibility.

Read More →
zonar system image
SponsoredJuly 1, 2026

Why More Drivers Won’t Fix the Shortage

Hiring isn’t enough. Learn how leading fleets are solving driver shortages through smarter retention, training, and culture strategies.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for School Bus Fleet ConneX (SBFX) 2026 announcing keynote speaker Ann Vote. The image features a headshot of Vote, a leadership and workplace culture coach, alongside event branding and text noting her appearance at SBFX 2026. A background photo shows attendees networking outdoors at a resort-style venue.
Managementby StaffJune 30, 2026

SBFX Keynote Announced: Ann Vote to Share Tips on Leadership and Team Culture

Find out who will be providing this year's keynote at SBFX in Scottsdale this September and what else to expect. District and contractor bus operators are invited to apply and attend at no cost!

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Thumbnail for a School Bus Fleet video titled "How School Buses Built America." The image features Amanda Huggett and school bus expert Brad Beauchamp in front of a faded background showing vintage yellow school buses. The School Bus Fleet logo appears above the title.
Managementby Amanda HuggettJune 29, 2026

The School Bus as an American Icon: Exploring the Past, Present, and Future of the Yellow Bus

As America approaches its 250th anniversary, Blue Bird's Brad Beauchamp explores the history of the yellow school bus, its impact on education, and where student transportation is headed next.

Read More →