SBF 70 years logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Report cites district-wide problems in Palm Beach busing debacle

A lack of clear leadership, a “culture of distrust” and inadequate staffing factored into the district’s school transportation meltdown this fall, an attorney finds.

Thomas McMahon
Thomas McMahonExecutive Editor
November 23, 2015
Report cites district-wide problems in Palm Beach busing debacle

When the new school year began, Palm Beach County was plagued with late and overcrowded buses and widespread routing problems.

3 min to read


WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. — A lack of clear leadership, a “culture of distrust” and inadequate staffing were among the factors involved in a school transportation meltdown here this fall, an independent report has found.

When the new school year began on Aug. 17, the School District of Palm Beach County was plagued with late and overcrowded buses and widespread routing problems.

Ad Loading...

The district implemented a new routing system before the beginning of the school year, and new Superintendent Robert Avossa said that there was not enough time for testing and training. He also noted that the district did not have enough school bus drivers to cover all of the routes in the required timeframe.

Avossa brought in an outside attorney, Eugene Pettis, to investigate the district’s transportation troubles.

According to Pettis’ report, released by the district on Wednesday, “The problems confronted during the August 2015 rollout of the routing software project were the result of multi-system failures throughout the School District.”

Pettis wrote that those failures, which were in such areas as leadership, collaboration and communications, “created an environment for the perfect storm and resulted in a failed project that should have been foreseeable and avoidable.”

As one example, Pettis found that the Palm Beach district has a chain-of-command problem. Employees often circumvent their supervisors and go to upper management, according to the report, which leads to supervisors being left out of important communications.

Ad Loading...

Another factor in the transportation debacle, Pettis found, was the district’s “culture of distrust that paralyzes individuals from giving their full potential.”

The report also cites inadequate staffing for the project and the routing department, and it suggests that pressure from a school board member to launch a parental app for the start of the school year led to the new routing system being rolled out “before it was fully developed and tested.”

In releasing Pettis' report last week, Palm Beach district officials said that much progress has been made in improving transportation over the past three months. As an example, school bus on-time performance is reportedly up to 95%. On the first day of school, the on-time rate was 60%.

In addition to Pettis’ investigation, Palm Beach commissioned a peer review by the Council of the Great City Schools, which will examine the district’s transportation services and offer recommendations for improvement.

“Once again I apologize for delays and struggles faced by our parents, students, teachers and administrators as a result of late and no-show buses,” Superintendent Avossa said. “I guarantee that we are working on a long term plan that will ensure that this does not happen again.”

Ad Loading...

To read Pettis’ full report, go here.

Watch a press conference held by Avossa on Wednesday in the video below.

More Management

A South Carolina Public Schools school bus lineup with text reading "How To Make Routing Data Persuasive."
Managementby Elora HaynesJuly 21, 2026

School Transportation Data Is Only as Powerful as the Story It Tells

Leaders say turning operational metrics into student-centered narratives can help districts justify investments and improve service.

Read More →
Collage highlighting NYAPT's 50th anniversary conference, featuring awards presentations, NYAPT President Marc Medina speaking, packed educational sessions, and the event's "Back to the Future" theme celebrating 50 years of pupil transportation leadership.
Managementby StaffJuly 20, 2026

Photos: NYAPT Celebrates 50 Years at 2026 Conference & Trade Show

See highlights from NYAPT's 50th anniversary conference in Saratoga Springs, featuring educational sessions, awards, a trade show, networking, and more.

Read More →
Graphic for a School Bus Fleet news story showing a school bus, two students walking toward it, and the headline, "Ohio Considers Ending Transportation Payments," referring to proposed changes to student transportation policy.
Managementby Amanda HuggettJuly 19, 2026

Ohio Transportation Workgroup Calls for End to 'Impractical to Transport' Payments

A final report from Ohio's Pupil Transportation Workgroup proposes ending "impractical to transport" payments and expanding transportation options through regional partnerships, but not all industry pros agree on the approach.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A close up of a school bus stop arm with a graphic overlay. Text reads "California Districts Adopt Routing Platform."
Managementby Staff and News ReportsJuly 15, 2026

Transfinder Expands California Footprint with Multiple School District Wins

Six California school districts selected the company's routing platform and related transportation technology as Transfinder continues expanding its presence across the state.

Read More →
Promotional thumbnail for The Route podcast featuring School Bus Fleet Editor Amanda Huggett and NSTA Executive Director Curt Macysyn
ManagementJuly 15, 2026

NSTA's Curt Macysyn on Student Transportation History and What's Next

Hear from NSTA's executive director as we discuss student transportation's role in American history, federal regulation, driver recruitment, illegal passing, AI, and what might be next, in this Route interview.

Read More →
Promotional thumbnail for The Route podcast featuring School Bus Fleet Editor Amanda Huggett and NSTA Executive Director Curt Macysyn. The episode, titled "The School Bus and America 250 and Legal Updates," discusses the school bus as an American icon and recent legislative developments affecting student transportation.
Sponsoredby Amanda HuggettJuly 14, 2026

NSTA on 250 Years of America and the Road Ahead for Student Transportation

Curt Macysyn joins The Route to discuss student transportation's role in American history, federal regulation, driver recruitment, illegal passing, AI, and the industry’s future. Sponsored by IC Bus.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A new Blue Bird school bus is lifted on a heavy-duty Rotary vehicle hoist during an outdoor maintenance equipment demonstration as attendees gather nearby.
Managementby Amanda HuggettJuly 13, 2026

Photo Highlights: Inside the 2026 Michigan Association for Pupil Transportation Conference

Snapshots from the 2026 MAPT conference, where Michigan's school transportation professionals gathered for training, technology updates, awards, networking, and more.

Read More →
Promotional image of Zonar's Bus Suite platform displayed on a desktop monitor, tablet, and smartphone, showcasing dashboards for ridership analytics, route management, GPS tracking, and real-time student transportation operations.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseJuly 10, 2026

Zonar Launches Reimagined Bus Suite Web Portal

Can one platform replace your transportation software stack? Zonar says its new Bus Suite unifies routing, dispatch, field trips, GPS, and parent communication.

Read More →
Three award winners pose with their awards.
Managementby Elora HaynesJuly 9, 2026

Indiana Association Announces 2026 Award Winners

See who earned top honors at the 2026 School Transportation Association of Indiana conference, recognizing excellence in school transportation statewide.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic announcing an acquisition in the school transportation industry, featuring the Student Transportation of America (STA) and Tremblay's Bus Company logos over a background of parked yellow school buses, with the headline "Acquisition News" and School Bus Fleet branding.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseJuly 8, 2026

Student Transportation of America Acquires Massachusetts Contractor

Tremblay’s Bus Company and its 400-bus fleet joins the STA family of brands as the company grows its presence across the Northeast U.S.

Read More →