FARMINGTON, Utah — A school district here is settling a lawsuit in the amount of $62,500 after a student was caught by his backpack in the bus's door and dragged, in what the boy's mother said was a racially-motivated incident.
In May, Brenda Mayes, the mother of the boy, sued Davis School District, according to USA Today. She alleged that the bus driver, John Naisbitt, 78, purposely closed the bus door on the backpack of her son, who is biracial, as he was getting off the bus. Surveillance video of the incident, which occurred on Feb. 4, shows several students deboarding before Naisbitt apparently closes the door behind the boy believed to be Mayes’ son, USA Today reports. The boy’s backpack straps were caught in the door before the bus drove approximately 150 to 175 feet. The boy, who was pinned to the outside of the door, was not injured in the incident, according to the news source.
Mayes alleged that school district officials didn’t address Naisbitt’s history of racial discrimination, harassment, and bullying of her son and other minority students, USA Today reports. She accused Naisbitt of racially-charged misconduct against students since September 2017, citing examples such as closing the bus door on two other biracial boys, calling students “stupid” and “idiots,” and not stopping a white student from assaulting a younger Asian student, according to KSTU.
Naisbitt, who told KSTU that he retired three days after the incident occurred to avoid being fired over it, said that he is not racist and mentioned the color of his dog as proof. He also told the news source that eight buses were lined up behind his bus when he warned the students he was pulling the bus forward, and that the incident was staged after he disciplined the boy’s brother. He added that he didn’t see the boy, and if he had, he would have stopped.
Shauna Lund, a spokesperson for Davis School District, said in a statement to USA Today that district officials “take these matters very seriously and do everything we can to protect students.”
District Settles Lawsuit After Biracial Student Dragged by School Bus
The Utah mother of a boy who was dragged when his backpack got caught in the door accuses the driver of a history of racially-motivated discrimination and bullying. Davis School District settles in the amount of $62,500.
More Management
All About Cooperative Purchasing: A Guide for School Transportation Pros
Stop bidding everything and try a simpler way. Here's how cooperative purchasing can streamline purchases while maintaining compliance. Sourcewell breaks down the process in this episode of The Route, sponsored by IC Bus.
Read More →
EverDriven Launches New School Bus Routing Services
The alternative transportation company expands its services to traditional yellow buses with the launch of a new division focused on helping school districts optimize their routes.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Joshua Roberts of First Student
Roberts, 35, serves as the lead IT application engineer for vehicle electrification at First Student, where he helps shape scalable, real-world EV infrastructure to support student transportation.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Quavion Swazer of Puyallup School District
Swazer, 29, serves as director of transportation at Puyallup School District, where he champions student wellbeing and inspires the next generation of industry leaders.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Katia Dubas of IMMI
Dubas, 38, serves as sales manager and safety advocate at IMMI, where she advances school bus occupant protection through industry education, OEM collaboration, and proactive safety policy efforts.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Eric Kramlick of TransPar
Kramlick, 30, runs operations for TransPar in Hawaii, where he also showed dedication while helping Maui recover from the recent wildfires.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Jonquez Moore of Little Elm ISD
Moore, 32, grew up around the school bus, leading him to the classroom and eventually inspiring high-performing teams while bringing operations in house (twice).
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Joshua Baran of Odyssey Charter School
Baran, 38, serves as transportation supervisor at Odyssey Charter School in Delaware, where he leads daily operations with a focus on safety and professional growth.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Tyler Maybee of Denver Public Schools
Maybee, 36, leads transportation operations for Denver Public Schools, where he is advancing equity, efficiency, and cross-department collaboration to improve student access.
Read More →
2026 Trailblazer: Lexi Higgins of TAT
Higgins, 38, serves as director of industry engagement at TAT (Truckers Against Trafficking), where she equips school transportation professionals with the tools to recognize and report human trafficking.
Read More →
