SBF 70 years logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Amputee Gets Job Back, But No Damages

CASE TODD A. PORTER v. ARTHUR A. ELLIS VENUE U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Filed July 10, 2002 SUMMARY A school bus driver wh...

November 1, 2002
2 min to read


CASE TODD A. PORTER v. ARTHUR A. ELLIS VENUE U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Filed July 10, 2002 SUMMARY A school bus driver whose left leg was amputated below the knee was laid off after the Michigan Department of Education refused to grant him an endorsement to drive a school bus. He filed a civil rights lawsuit against the superintendent of public instruction for the Department of Education, seeking an injunction and monetary damages. The trial court dismissed his action against the superintendent. The driver appealed the decision to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan. BACKGROUND Todd Porter, a resident of Kalamazoo, Mich., had his left leg amputated below the knee in 1990 after he was injured in an automobile accident. He uses a prosthetic leg to compensate for his injury. From September 1997 to September 1998, Porter worked as a school bus driver for Kalamazoo Public Schools. From September 1998 to September 1999, he drove a bus for Laidlaw Transit Inc. in Kalamazoo. On March 21, 2000, Laidlaw laid Porter off after the Michigan Department of Education refused to grant him an endorsement to drive a school bus, apparently because of his disability. On Aug. 7, 2000, Porter filed a civil rights lawsuit against Arthur Ellis, superintendent of the Michigan Department of Education. In his complaint, Porter did not allege that Ellis was personally involved in the Department of Education’s decision not to grant him an endorsement. Instead, Porter asked that Ellis write a letter ordering Laidlaw to rehire him. He also sought to collect monetary damages from Ellis. DECISION During the appeal process, a Michigan state court compelled the Michigan Department of Education to inform Laidlaw that Porter was eligible to return to work. Thus, the only issue before the appeals court was Porter’s claim for monetary damages. The court cited a 1982 case that found that liability of supervisory personnel may not stem from their position of authority. To state a supportable claim, the plaintiff must allege that the supervisory official “implicitly authorized, approved or knowingly acquiesced” in the unconstitutional or statutorily violative conduct that is the subject of his claim.” Porter made no such allegations in his claim. Nor did he make any significant connection between Ellis and the adverse action taken by the Michigan Department of Education. Although Porter submitted two letters in Ellis’ name, neither letter actually denied Porter the endorsement he sought. Moreover, it was later shown that Ellis was not the author of either of the letters. The judgment of the lower court was affirmed.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

Technician using a laptop to diagnose and service a school bus engine, highlighting fleet maintenance technology and transportation operations.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 14, 2026

Paper Routes Get an Upgrade: Louisiana District Turns to New Service Model

Lafourche Parish Schools will implement First Student’s Fleet-as-a-Service model for 115 buses, shifting maintenance and operations on-site ahead of the 2026-27 school year.

Read More →
Graphic promoting “40 Ideas for Your Next In-Service Training,” featuring photos of school transportation training activities including wheelchair securement practice, a bus safety demonstration, and maintenance inspection beside a yellow school bus, with School Bus Fleet branding.
Managementby Amanda HuggettApril 13, 2026

In-Service Planning Made Easier: Tips for a Smooth Back-to-School Start

Snag your summer prep checklist for school transportation directors, plus 40 training topic ideas to bring to your team.

Read More →
a faded photo of school buses in the background with the samsara logo and IC Bus logo next to each other
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 10, 2026

IC Bus, Samsara Launch Pre-Delivery Telematics Installation Program

New IC Bus vehicles can now arrive with Samsara telematics factory-installed, helping fleets reduce downtime, streamline setup, and achieve day-one connectivity.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An image of a school bus driving on a road in Malibu with text reading "2026 Industry Honors in School Transportation."
Managementby StaffApril 10, 2026

School Transportation Companies Earn Top Honors in 2026

From tech advancements to standout workplace cultures, see which key players across the school transportation sector are earning national recognition.

Read More →
Managementby StaffApril 6, 2026

Enter Now: School Bus Fleet’s 2026 Photo of the Year Contest

We're looking for winner-worthy photos of the big yellow bus, so grab your cameras and start snapping your best shots. SBF’s Photo of the Year contest is open and accepting entries through May 31.

Read More →
An aerial view of school buses in a lot with the Transfinder logo and text reading "New District Installs Across the Nation."
Managementby Staff and News ReportsApril 2, 2026

Transfinder Expands Footprint with New District Adoptions Across U.S.

Districts nationwide are adopting Transfinder’s routing, tracking, and parent apps as the company also earns its ninth Best Companies to Work for in New York honor.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Zonar Bus Suite app shown on smartphones with map tracking and language selection options, highlighting multilingual support for school transportation updates.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 2, 2026

Zonar Expands Parent App to Include 2 More Languages

The Bus Suite app is now supported in French and Spanish to aid in assisting families across diverse communities.

Read More →
The Blue Bird and Micro Bird logos with a plus sign in between against a blue background
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 2, 2026

Blue Bird Completes Acquisition of Micro Bird, Consolidates Operations

The Georgia-based OEM has acquired Girardin Group’s stake in the 50/50 Micro Bird joint venture, bringing the business fully under one brand, one team and one operating approach.

Read More →
A yellow graphic featuring a map of the United States with two location pins in the Midwest and Southeast regions. To the right is the Zum logo and text reading “Zum Enters 2 More Partnerships,” with the School Bus Fleet logo in the corner.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 1, 2026

Zum Adds 2 More District Partnerships

The transportation and software provider is now working with LEAD Public Schools in Tennessee and Rockford Public Schools in Illinois.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic titled “Cooperative Purchasing 101” from School Bus Fleet showing a team meeting around a table with a laptop, documents, and a toy school bus, promoting easier ways to buy buses and technology.
Managementby Amanda HuggettApril 1, 2026

Stop Reinventing the RFP: Why Cooperative Purchasing Works for School Transportation

Take the burden out of bidding. Cooperative contracts can save district transportation teams time, money, and hassle. Here’s how.

Read More →