The state directors association strengthened its position in support of lap-shoulder belts for school buses, a key development during the group’s annual conference in Grand Rapids, Mich., in October.

Previously, the National Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services (NASDPTS) had gone on the record to support lap-shoulder belts if funding is made available for them. But that statement had begun to seem inconsequential considering economic conditions.

“All of us know that funding is not currently generally available, and I doubt anyone thinks it will become available anytime in the near future,” NASDPTS President Max Christensen said. “Thus our position really seemed to be a ‘non-position.’”

At the Grand Rapids gathering, the NASDPTS board decided to bolster its support for the three-point restraints by dropping the funding clause from its position.

“As of today, NASDPTS fully supports the installation and use of lap-shoulder belts in school buses, period, with no ifs, ands or buts,” Christensen said.

However, the board noted that it should be left up to school districts whether to equip their buses with the restraints.

“We are not recommending the installation and use, nor are we asking that lap-shoulder belts be required,” Christensen said. “We believe this should be a local decision based on local need.”

NASDPTS’ position papers on the topic will be updated to reflect the new position.

Seat belts on school buses has been a contentious topic in the industry for several decades, but Christensen said that the NASDPTS board felt it was time to take “a true leadership position” on the issue.


Attendees watch the heartrending film “Impact: After the Crash,” on the catastrophic bus crash and fire in Carrollton, Ky., in 1988. On screen is Harold Dennis, who escaped from the bus but was severely burned.

Attendees watch the heartrending film “Impact: After the Crash,” on the catastrophic bus crash and fire in Carrollton, Ky., in 1988. On screen is Harold Dennis, who escaped from the bus but was severely burned.

Michigan matters
During NASDPTS conference sessions at the DeVos Place Convention Center, on the banks of the chilly Grand River, attendees heard from several Michigan officials involved in transportation safety. That included a welcome from state pupil transportation director Ken Micklash and an overview of the Michigan Traffic Crash Facts website (, which allows users to analyze accidents involving school buses, among other vehicles.

Sgt. Mike McLaughlin of the Michigan State Police shared details on changes to the state’s school bus inspection program. The agency is implementing tablets for its inspectors and moving to an electronic inspection form, which McLaughlin said will increase efficiency and access to key information.
“All the data that’s in there will be searchable,” he said. “We’re going to have more data available to us than we even realize now.”

Crash analyses
NASDPTS held two joint keynote sessions with the National Association for Pupil Transportation (NAPT). Both of those presentations examined fatal bus crashes.

Christopher Hart, vice chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board, discussed his agency’s investigations of two similar school bus accidents in 2012 — one in Chesterfield, N.J., and the other in Port St. Lucie, Fla. In the other session, attendees watched a documentary on the 1988 Carrollton, Ky., bus tragedy. (For more on those two sessions, see this article.)

Also during the joint gathering of NASDPTS and NAPT attendees, the American School Bus Council presented its School Bus Champions award to Washington State Superintendent Randy Dorn and his chief of staff, Ken Kanikeberg. Both have been instrumental in increasing pupil transportation funding and protecting regional coordinator positions in their state.

“During the last [legislative] session, they secured another $109 million in funding for pupil transportation in Washington for the next two years,” said Don Carnahan, former Washington state pupil transportation director and now president of NAPT. “This is not a one-time deal for these gentlemen. They have actively supported pupil transportation initiatives for many years.”

Variety of topics
Other NASDPTS sessions included:
• Donny Bynum, superintendent of Dale County (Ala.) Schools, shared his district’s experiences and lessons learned in the early 2013 incident in which school bus driver Charles “Chuck” Poland Jr. was fatally shot and a 5-year-old student was taken hostage.
• Launi Hardin, transportation director at Washington County School District in St. George, Utah, discussed Obamacare and its implications for school districts and their bus drivers.
• Washington state pupil transportation director Allan Jones put a humorous spin on his presentation about marijuana legalization in Washington and its possible effects on school bus drivers.

The 2014 NASDPTS conference will be held in Kansas City, Mo., Nov. 9-12.

About the author
Thomas McMahon

Thomas McMahon

Executive Editor

Thomas had covered the pupil transportation industry with School Bus Fleet since 2002. When he's not writing articles about yellow buses, he enjoys running long distances and making a joyful noise with his guitar.

View Bio