School Bus Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NSTA Advocacy in Action — Safety Fitness Proposal Would Leave Safe Carriers Unrated

The NSTA believes the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's proposal would offer very limited guidance on the safety record of some carriers and cause confusion.

by Ronna Weber
September 14, 2016
NSTA Advocacy in Action  — Safety Fitness Proposal Would Leave Safe Carriers Unrated

The NSTA has several concerns over a notice of proposed rulemaking on safety fitness determination from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. Photo by Derek Graham

3 min to read


The NSTA has several concerns over a notice of proposed rulemaking on safety fitness determination from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. Photo by Derek Graham

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) released a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) on safety fitness determination earlier this year. The National School Transportation Association’s (NSTA’s) Advocacy in Action column last month provided the issue’s history. An explanation of why NSTA opposes the proposal follows.

NSTA has several concerns with FMCSA’s safety fitness determination proposal: the proposed change in the rating system; the proposed change in methodology to determine an unfit carrier; and the disregard for the congressionally directed procedures for undertaking a significant rulemaking.

The current safety fitness rating system ranks a carrier as “satisfactory,” “conditional,” or “unsatisfactory” based on a comprehensive safety compliance review. This system aligns well with the safety culture within the school transportation industry as well as the safety culture that is expected by the public and the enforcement community. By viewing these ratings, there is no doubt as to the status of the carrier.

However, we recognize that many carriers are unrated under this system. FMCSA’s safety fitness determination proposal would radically modify the safety fitness rating system, and the new methodology would be based on on-road safety data in relation to five of the agency’s seven behavior analysis and safety improvement categories (BASICs), an investigation, or a combination of on-road safety data and investigation information.

Rather than recognize a safe carrier as being safe, FMCSA’s proposal would simply leave a safe carrier unrated, offering very limited guidance on the safety record of the carrier and causing potential confusion among carriers, law enforcement, and the public.
Ad Loading...

NSTA has grave concerns about the method proposed in this rulemaking. The proposed new system would remove all existing ratings and create only one rating, “unfit.” Rather than recognize a safe carrier as being safe, FMCSA’s proposal would simply leave a safe carrier unrated, offering very limited guidance on the safety record of the carrier and causing potential confusion among carriers, law enforcement, and the public.

This rating change, which lacks common sense, is culturally flawed as it seeks only to recognize carriers that do not adhere to the regulations while failing to positively acknowledge those that invest time, resources, and personnel into being in compliance and operating safely.

The FAST (Fixing America’s Surface Transportation) Act directed a National Academy of Sciences study and contained several provisions addressing regulatory reform at FMCSA. This section specifically advised that if a proposed rule is going to lead to a major rule, FMCSA must first begin with an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) or a negotiated rulemaking.

Ronna Weber is executive director of the National School Transportation Association (NSTA).

In this case, FMCSA utilized a waiver requirement in the law that permits the agency to waive the requirement if it deems an ANPRM impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to the public interest. The safety fitness determination proposal is a very significant proposal that would fundamentally alter the rating system used to determine the safety of a commercial motor vehicle carrier and alter the paradigm in which the new rating occurs.

By sidestepping the ANPRM stage or deciding not to form a negotiated rulemaking committee, FMCSA is choosing to begin the discussion with its own proposal, rather than seeking input from the very motor carriers the proposal would affect.

Many motor carriers have offered criticism of the CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) system and its safety measurement scores, agreeing with the school transportation industry that it is based on flawed data. For FMCSA to ignore that criticism and continue to push forward — while also offering a proposal without first seeking input from its affected audience — is misguided.

FMCSA has on two recent instances chosen to utilize the ANPRM (in the case of obstructive sleep apnea) and the negotiated rulemaking (for entry-level driver training) processes, and NSTA sees no reason why the agency could not proceed with either of those methods on the safety fitness determination rulemaking because it will have such a significant impact on all regulated commercial motor vehicle operators, including the school transportation industry.

NSTA opposes this proposal. FMCSA needs to address the issues that have been identified in the CSA program before trying to move forward on any proposal that would utilize the same data and information.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Safety

School Bus Fleet’s The Route podcast thumbnail featuring a smiling woman with glasses and the headline “Rockwall ISD’s Award-Winning Safety Culture” against a gold background.
Safety•November 13, 2026

How a Texas District Built an Award-Winning Safety Culture

Rockwall ISD's Jennifer Gardella joins The Route to share lessons learned on accident prevention, driver training, coaching, technology, and team culture.

Read More →
School Bus Fleet’s The Route podcast thumbnail featuring two women and the headline “How Rockwall ISD Built an Award-Winning Safety Culture,” with School Bus Fleet’s 70th anniversary logo and sponsor logo.
Safety•by Amanda Huggett•November 13, 2026

How Rockwall ISD Built an Award-Winning Safety Culture

How did one Texas transportation team strengthen bus and traffic safety? Jennifer Gardella shares lessons on driver training, coaching, technology, and team culture. The Route is brought to you by IC Bus.

Read More →
School Bus Fleet graphic featuring a yellow school bus with a shattered glass effect and the headline “NC Student Killed While Boarding School Bus & Two Die in Utah Bus Crash,” dated November 3, 2026.
Safety•by Elora Haynes•November 5, 2026

North Carolina Student Killed While Boarding School Bus, Two Die in Utah Bus Crash

A Southern Nash High School student died after being struck by a pickup truck while approaching her school bus. In a separate incident, two people were killed after crashing into a school bus in Utah.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Two workers in high-visibility shirts install yellow flexible bollards along a residential street crosswalk in Minneapolis as part of a pilot project to improve school zone safety.
Safety•by Amanda Huggett•November 4, 2026

Minneapolis School Zone Pilot Cuts Speeding 41% with Low-Cost Street Design Changes

In a pilot project in Minnesota, two school-area intersections had low-cost, temporary road and traffic flow improvements made to measure the impact on roadway and student safety. Here's what they found.

Read More →
Yellow Safety Vision school bus stop-arm camera beside text reading “Turning Cameras Into Accountability in Connecticut,” with faded video monitoring software screens in the background.
Safety•by News/Media Release•November 4, 2026

Sitestream, Safety Vision Partner with Connecticut City to Launch School Bus Stop-Arm Camera Program

The new enforcement initiative combines camera technology and violation management software to document illegal school bus passing, encourage driver compliance, and enhance student safety.

Read More →
A compilation of 3 images showing a computer monitor, a person holding a smartphone, and a female on the phone
Sponsored•November 1, 2026

From Reactive to Proactive: Making Every Ride Visible

Smart technology only delivers its full value when it works together. See how Catalyst connects proven industry platforms to move student transportation from reactive to proactive.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Vehicle dashboard display showing a “Caution: School Bus Stopped Ahead” warning from HAAS Alert’s Safety Cloud system, designed to alert motorists to stopped school buses.
Safety•October 29, 2026

HAAS Alert’s Safety Cloud Warns Motorists of Stopped School Buses

Through a transponder or Samsara connection, the product lets school bus fleets send advance warnings to approaching drivers through in-vehicle alerts.

Read More →
Four women participate in a council meeting around a wooden conference table, with one speaking while the others listen. Laptops, notebooks, and drinks sit on the table.
Safety•by News/Media Release•October 23, 2026

HopSkipDrive Reports Progress on Safety Advisory Council

More than a year after forming the council, independent safety experts have helped shape new rider-safety features and policy progress, with a new goal to address rider behavior.

Read More →
School Bus Fleet graphic showing students boarding a yellow school bus with the headline “Senate Recognized National School Bus Safety Month for 13th Year.”
Safety•by Elora Haynes•October 22, 2026

What the 2026 National School Bus Safety Month Resolution Means for Student Transportation

The bipartisan resolution highlights illegal school bus passing, student safety during loading and unloading, and the need for driver training and public education.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Close-up of a stop-arm enforcement camera mounted on a yellow school bus, with the headline “When Enforcement Drives Safety” and the School Bus Fleet logo.
Safety•by Amanda Huggett•October 20, 2026

School Bus Stop-Arm Violations Decline 53% Across Verra Mobility Programs

Verra Mobility shares how school bus stop-arm cameras and school zone safety programs are changing driver behavior, reducing violations, and protecting students.

Read More →