Pros and cons of students riding transit buses

Ted Finlayson-Schueler
Posted on February 21, 2013
Ted Finlayson-Schueler is president of Safety Rules!, a nonprofit organization based in Syracuse, N.Y.
Ted Finlayson-Schueler is president of Safety Rules!, a nonprofit organization based in Syracuse, N.Y.

Transit bus transportation has certainly not operated under the same microscope as school bus transportation as far as student safety is concerned. I served, along with Ron Kinney [state legislation monitor for the National School Transportation Association, a consultant, and former state director of school transportation for California], who is quoted in the blog, on the Transportation Research Board’s study committee that created the report “The Relative Risks of School Travel.” (It can be downloaded at

The committee searched for data to compare the “relative risk” of school and transit buses and was not able to pinpoint data on student transit fatalities because, No. 1, students are not an established subset of transit ridership. No. 2, once riders have stepped off a transit bus, they are no longer counted as being related to the transit bus. If they are struck by the bus, they are just a pedestrian, not a passenger/pedestrian. If the rider is hit by another vehicle while crossing the street after alighting, the transit bus doesn’t appear on the accident report.

All this said, a strong transit system can play an important role in high school education. (I hesitate to include middle school because that term can include children as young as fourth or fifth grade in some school districts.) If education at these levels could be easily partitioned into activities that started at 8 a.m. and ended at 2:30 p.m. (you can pick any other a.m. or p.m. times), then our yellow buses could meet the needs of these students handily.

Unfortunately, there are some before-school activities, many days when testing schedules or other special activities mean students don’t need to be at school first thing in the morning, and many, many activities after the school day ends. If these older students get to and from school with a transit pass they can use at any time an activity is scheduled, they have the opportunity to participate in these activities. If their parents don’t have a car and the late buses have been cut (which is often the first service on the budget chopping block), then involvement in non-curricular activities becomes a choice between non-participation and riding with teens (something so dangerous that a comparison between school bus and transit bus safety becomes superfluous). These “extra” activities are what keep some students in school and what other students use to show themselves as being “well-rounded” in college applications.

If transit bus transportation is chosen for middle and high school students, ridership safety must be taught just as intensely as we teach school bus safety to our yellow bus students. The additional benefit to teaching transit bus safety is that it is a skill that the students can use their entire lifetime.

The one-size-fits-all yellow bus arrival and departure times may provide the safest form of surface transportation, but it does not support the schedules and needs of our students. Unless we can develop the flexibility to meet our students’ transportation needs and we can find a way to make yellow buses appear relevant to them, we will not be the transportation of choice for students or for educators — not for the financial reasons that began this discussion, but because transit’s flexibility is the only way to deal with the diverse aspects of secondary school education that include schools of choice, homeless children, community service, online courses, courses on college campuses, work study, internships and GED programs, along with traditional after-school programs and athletics.

Related Topics: transit/tripper service

Comments ( 2 )
  • See all comments

     | about 7 years ago

    It is depressing when economics out weigh safety. How thankful we are for educators that but the safety of their students first!!!

More Stories
The NCST’s Steering Committees and writing committees are preparing for the 2020 Congress. Murrell Martin (shown left) and Bill Loshbough are shown here leading a discussion at NCST 2015.

NCST Gears Up for 2020

The National Congress on School Transportation Steering Committee firms up plans and writing committees are researching requests for procedures manual changes. The Congress will meet in Des Moines, Iowa, in May.

Jed Routh, former logistics manager for Thomas Built Buses, is the manufacturer's new vice president of sales, service, and marketing. He replaces long-time Thomas Built veteran Ken Hedgecock. Photo courtesy Thomas Built Buses

Thomas Built Buses Names New Sales, Marketing VP

Jed Routh, former logistics manager for the manufacturer’s operations team, is the new vice president of sales, service, and marketing. He replaces long-time Thomas Built veteran Ken Hedgecock.

More than 100 attendees joined the federal issues forum with Bruce Landsberg, vice chairman for the National Transportation Safety Board. He went over several of the agency’s safety recommendations, including those for physical performance testing, evacuation training, and fire suppression systems.

PHOTOS: Highlights from NAPT Conference in Columbus

A hands-on team-building exercise, sessions and awards addressing safety and industry achievement, and a trade show showcasing the latest technology were some of the highlights at this year's NAPT conference.

NAPT President Barry Sudduth presented Peter Mannella (right), longtime NAPT member and former executive director of the New York Association for Pupil Transportation, with the association's Distinguished Service Award. 

NAPT Awards Highlight Top-Notch Service, Achievement

Student transportation professionals are recognized for their remarkable dedication and service to the school bus industry. Awards are also presented to Zonar’s 2019 Don Carnahan Memorial grant recipients.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!