Never forget the danger of leaving a child behind

Thomas McMahon
Posted on September 28, 2015
Thomas McMahon is executive editor of School Bus Fleet.

Thomas McMahon is executive editor of School Bus Fleet.

If you monitor the nation’s media outlets for school bus news, as we do here at SBF, you’ll occasionally see stories about students being left unattended on school buses.

These incidents are relatively rare, considering that more than 25 million children in the U.S. are transported daily on yellow buses. But when they do happen, they put kids at risk and often lead to termination for the school bus driver.

Over the years, we’ve reported on many incidents of students being left stranded on school buses. We’ve published feature articles with tips on how to prevent these incidents — in fact, there is just such an article in our new October issue (“10 Tips to Bolster Bus Checks for Sleepers”).

In some cases, children are left alone on a bus for multiple hours. These incidents are traumatic for the child and his or her parents, but they typically haven’t resulted in serious physical harm to the child.

Tragically, the outcome was much worse on a school bus in Whittier, California, on Sept. 11 — already an infamous date. As previously reported, Hun Joon “Paul” Lee died after being left stranded on his school bus on a day when temperatures climbed into triple digits in some areas.

As of this writing, the autopsy on Lee has not yet been released, and officials have not yet confirmed exactly how long the autistic 19-year-old was left on the bus (his family members have told local media that they believe he was stranded for about nine hours).

What is clear is that the school bus driver did not find Lee on the bus when he should have — in a post-trip check of the bus.

There are various measures that school bus operations can implement to ensure that students aren’t left behind on their buses, but none of these measures is foolproof. The key is to implement multiple measures — to build in redundancy.

For example, drivers can be required to conduct two checks per run: one when the bus becomes empty and another upon returning to the depot. Electronic child-reminder systems can be installed on buses, or simpler devices like a “BUS EMPTY” sign can be hung in the rear window of the bus. Managers can issue frequent reminders on the topic, and they can be visible in the yard when checks are being done.

A spokesperson for the Pupil Transportation Cooperative, the operator of Lee’s bus, told reporters in a news conference that the agency is enhancing its safety procedures, including having two staff members check each bus for students and implementing an electronic child-check system.

As Wave Wire Services reported, the spokesperson called the tragedy “a teachable moment for this organization.”

In fact, the tragedy can be a teachable moment for all school bus operations. Lee’s death can serve as a poignant reminder of the importance of thoroughly checking every school bus after every run.

As a nation, we’ve already committed to “never forget” the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. Now, the pupil transportation community must never forget the death of Paul Lee on Sept. 11, 2015.

Thomas McMahon Executive Editor
Comments ( 3 )
  • See all comments
  • Kathi Hope

     | about 4 years ago

    We have the, 'No Child Left Behind', alarms on our buses. After shutting down the bus & making sure the light & stop arm activator switch is off, we must go to the back of the bus & push the button, to deactivate the alarm, before opening the door. If not, the horn honks repeatedly, until button is pressed. Sometimes after a route, you may sit there a moment, to write up an unruly rider or take a call, before going to clock out. Some of us have opened the door without thinking about it, til the honking starts. I've driven buses of some sort since mid 1991. I haven't always had alarms on my buses, but I know my riders. I've had only 2 sleepers in my career, but never a child unaccounted for.

More Stories
NAPT Conference and Trade Show scholarship deadlines are almost here. Shown here is Michael Martin, NAPT's executive director, speaking at the 2018 conference in Kansas City, Mo.

NAPT Scholarship Deadlines Approaching

The National Association for Pupil Transportation Conference and Trade Show deadline for two related scholarships is Sept. 18. The Sol Englander Innovation in School Transportation Safety Scholarship deadline is Oct. 11.

Isabel Lane of Wisconsin held the hand of a frightened student on his first day of school. A photo of the gesture taken by his mother is widely shared on social media. Photo courtesy Amy Johnson

Bus Driver Comforts Student on First Day of School

Isabel Lane of Wisconsin reaches her hand out to a frightened student on his first day of school after he boards the bus. A photo of the gesture taken by his mother is widely shared on social media.

Francine Furby, the director of transportation for Fairfax County Public Schools, says that the district’s discipline-tracking system “fosters a partnership with the schools and strengthens their support of our drivers.” Photo courtesy Fairfax County Public Schools

Virginia District Bolsters Driver Support for Success

Fairfax County Public Schools backs its 1,325 drivers with a discipline-tracking system for better follow-up and puts driver supervisors on the road to assist as needed. Additionally, fleet upkeep is boosted with county-employed technicians.

Glenda Daughtry, who recently retired, had worked as a bus driver and teacher’s aide for Sampson County Schools in Clinton, N.C. Many districts in the state require certain staff members to obtain their CDL and drive buses when needed. Photo courtesy Vicki Westbrook

Helping School Bus Drivers Turn Downtime Into Uptime

Texas and North Carolina transportation departments fill the gap in drivers’ schedules with work opportunities beyond more routes, such as administrative, cleaning, and technical tasks, and tap other staff to ease driver shortage. Meanwhile, an Illinois contractor offers space for socializing and relaxation.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!