Special Needs Transportation

Charges Dropped Against Aide Accused of Abusing Special-Needs Students

Posted on January 7, 2019

LAKE COUNTY, Fla. — Charges against a school bus aide who was accused of abusing special-needs students were dropped based on a state law that allows corporal punishment in schools, WFTV reports.

Lake County Sheriff’s Office deputies told the news source that an investigation into James Charles Brunson, 26, began on May 17 when the Department of Children and Families notified them of the allegations against him, after one of the students on his bus came home with a minor injury.

A news release from the Lake County Sheriff’s office stated that bus video from May 15 routes showed Brunson, who worked for Lake County Schools, grabbing students by their faces, twisting their heads and arms, pushing them against the wall of the bus, placing a shoe over one student's mouth, and stretching one boy's leg over his head, ClickOrlando.com reports. Deputies also told the news source that the video showed Brunson pulling on the harnesses of the seats. Brunson was arrested on 32 counts of child abuse on June 25.

However, those charges were dropped because the state’s attorney’s office said that Florida law allows parents and other adults to use corporal punishment, arguing that the four children involved in the incident were "kicking and punching other students,” and "screaming, hitting defendant," so "defendant's behavior arguably falls under the corporal punishment privilege given his role as a bus monitor," according to WFTV. The attorney’s office also said, the news source reports, that the aide’s conduct "does not rise to the level of criminal child abuse."

The school district told the news source that corporal punishment is not allowed in its classrooms or on its buses, that Brunson will never work for the district again, and that it is placing more emphasis on de-escalation and student management when training new bus monitors.

Related Topics: aide/monitor, driver training, Florida

Comments ( 1 )
  • Nancy

     | about 3 months ago

    This whole story blows my mind.

More Stories
A video about the career of special-needs school bus driver Karen Sweet was one of the standout videos posted on SBF's website in 2018.

Editor's Picks 2018: Videos of the Year

A career spotlight on one special-needs school bus driver and second graders teaching school bus safety were a couple of School Bus Fleet’s web highlights in 2018.

The NCST’s writing committees are seeking subject matter experts and public comment as they prepare for the 2020 Congress. Murrell Martin (shown left) and Bill Loshbough are shown here leading a discussion at NCST 2015.

NCST Writing Committees Seek Input

The National Congress on School Transportation’s writing committees are seeking subject matter experts and public comment as they prepare for the 2020 Congress. 


Aide Accused of Abusing Special-Needs Student

Arthur Carlos of California is reportedly shown on school bus video putting his hands around a boy’s neck and pushing his head against a window. He is charged with corporal injury upon a child.

NAPT inducted special-needs transportation expert Dr. Linda Bluth into its Hall of Fame.

NAPT Awards Highlight Training Efforts, Heroism

America’s Best competition winners and other student transportation professionals are recognized for training contributions. A student is honored for stepping in when his bus driver had a medical emergency.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!