5 Questions: Ted Finlayson-Schueler on Driver Training, NTSB Recommendations

Nicole Schlosser
Posted on August 12, 2019

Finlayson-Schueler says that the student transportation industry has to “convey the benefits of being employed in school transportation to attract and keep quality drivers and managers.”
Finlayson-Schueler says that the student transportation industry has to “convey the benefits of being employed in school transportation to attract and keep quality drivers and managers.”
Initially recognized post-college for his driving abilities, Ted Finlayson-Schueler left behind a series of odd jobs to drive a school bus. Soon after, he transitioned to the safety training side of student transportation, and eventually helped found the Pupil Transportation Safety Institute (PTSI). He formed Safety Rules, his own safety consulting nonprofit organization, in 2004, and has been helping to improve student safety on the bus ever since. Finlayson-Schueler also serves as an expert witness.

In this interview with School Bus Fleet, Finlayson-Schueler talks about the need to improve driver training, ways to curtail stop-arm running, and his take on some recent National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) safety recommendations.

1. How did you get your start in pupil transportation?

I was drifting in that “I-haven’t-finished-my-degree” wasteland and had done car sales, construction, and served as an assistant chaplain. I was helping a friend return a rental truck and he commented on how well I drove it. He suggested I apply for a bus driver job where his wife worked. I did — and I finished my degree.

I got into safety because I was at a wedding reception and my wife’s boss’s wife, who worked at a regional education entity, remembered that I drove buses and told me they received a grant for a safety center and I should apply. Fast forward four years and I was a safety expert.

2. What do you like most about your work?

Since 1985, I have been on the safety side, first running a state regional safety office for over 200 school districts in New York state, and then at PTSI and Safety Rules. I have met scores of wonderful people who are doing great things and have great ideas. I have tried to repurpose these into training and guidance in my writing and teaching. I enjoy hearing of or seeing a driver or attendant do or say the right thing and thinking that the materials I developed might have had some part in their learning.

3. This is an extremely safety-sensitive industry. There are many pressing issues — stop-arm running, bus fires, etc. What is the most urgent?

The low unemployment rate has heightened a longtime issue: driver quality. The jobs of school bus drivers and attendants are very difficult. The damage done by poor or poorly trained employees includes driving and bus stop accidents, children left on buses or dropped off miles from their homes, and being bullied or abused.

We have to figure out a way to convey the benefits of being employed in school transportation to attract and keep quality drivers and managers.

4. The NTSB recently made recommendations based on a fatal school bus fire in Iowa, mainly requiring fire suppression systems, annual physical performance tests, and reporting drivers with medical conditions that may make operating a school bus unsafe. What are your thoughts?

Fire suppression systems have been standard equipment on transit buses for years, so adding them to school buses operating in the same environment — and potentially with a more vulnerable passenger mix — makes sense. The systems will save buses, but there has been virtually no loss of life in school buses that would have been prevented by such a system. Other than the Iowa fire, which was entirely survivable with an able driver, we have the Carrollton, Ky., fire [in 1988], which was caused by a ruptured fuel tank, and would not have been suppressed by an engine compartment system advocated for by NTSB.

New York’s physical performance test model has been made standard by other states and large contractors. It seems clear that the Iowa driver would not have passed even this minimal standard.

A big weakness in the driver physical is that it allows drivers to self-report medical history and medications. I have seen this in multiple cases I have worked on. The examiner has no other source of information.

5. Are you seeing any new training requests?

The “new” requests are for the old stuff. So many new issues have arisen over the last 20 years that it seems like the focus has shifted away from basics like bus stop safety and defensive driving. We’ve been talking about it for decades, but school bus stops need to be executed better.

We, of course, need to get motorists to stop passing school buses that are loading or unloading, but we can’t let that obscure the fact that there are two solutions that we can implement without the aid of motorists.

California’s driver crossing system has been successful for decades.

Also, the commercial driver’s license (CDL) manual in almost every state is based on the federal recommendation for the “S” endorsement and includes a crossing procedure that drivers and students can use to avoid accidents. I have only seen one deposition of a driver in a court case who understands this procedure, and I have never had a case that would not have been avoided by using the procedure properly.

Related Topics: bus fires, driver training, NTSB, stop-arm running/illegal passing

Nicole Schlosser Executive Editor
Comments ( 1 )
  • Francisc B.

     | about 1 day ago

    Good Job Mr. Finlayson-Schueler !!!! - - - - - It's about time somebody brings up the procedures and SAFETY of the California Crossing System when it comes to kids safely getting to the other side. Hope it catches on and it gets implemented in every state.

More Stories

School Bus Songs: ‘I Drive A Bus And It’s All Because…’

Transportation staff at the School District of Manatee County (Fla.) put their own spin on Montell Jordan’s popular hit “This is How We Do It," showing what it takes to drive a big yellow bus. (The video concept was inspired by another parody posted in 2012 by Jeremy Byler.)

School Bus Fleet ConneX (SBFX) will convene in Scottsdale, Ariz., from April 22 to 24, 2020. Shown here is a roundtable discussion at the inaugural edition of SBFX, which was held in Miami, Fla., in April 2019.

School Bus Fleet ConneX to Return in 2020

Next year’s event will bring school bus operators and suppliers to Scottsdale, Ariz., for roundtable discussions, one-on-one meetings, and other networking activities.

The State Board of Education adopted rules to require lap-shoulder belts and other safety equipment in all new school buses purchased by school districts and state-accredited non-public schools. File photo courtesy Des Moines (Iowa) Public Schools

Iowa Moves Closer to Requiring Seat Belts on New School Buses

The State Board of Education adopts rules to require lap-shoulder belts and other safety equipment in all new school buses purchased by school districts and state-accredited non-public schools. The rules are subject to legislative review before taking effect.


Stop-Arm Camera System

The integrated stop-arm camera system from Pro-Vision Video Systems can automatically capture video evidence of vehicles that illegally pass stopped school buses. 

The 56th annual Iowa Pupil Transportation Association (IPTA) conference drew a total of 235 attendees. Attendees heard from a variety of experts including authors, accident investigators, and experts on federal and state laws. They also reviewed bus crash test data and video, and viewed demonstrations of disc brakes, evacuation drills, and school bus crashes. Shown here, attendees prepare to watch a school bus crash demonstration. Photo courtesy April Darling

PHOTOS: Iowa Pupil Transportation Association Conference

School bus officials, transportation directors, mechanics, and other student transportation employees from across the state gathered in Des Moines from July 15 to 17 to attend the Iowa Pupil Transportation Association’s annual conference.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!