Report Targets School Buses Caught on Camera Running Red Lights in New York

Thomas McMahon
Posted on October 19, 2017
A new report from the New York attorney general highlights red light camera citations issued to school bus companies. Photo by Unisouth via Wikimedia Commons
A new report from the New York attorney general highlights red light camera citations issued to school bus companies. Photo by Unisouth via Wikimedia Commons

New York’s attorney general is calling for more oversight of school bus citations from traffic cameras, even as opponents of traffic cameras call for the removal of the devices.

On Tuesday — notably during National School Bus Safety Week — New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman released a report titled “Wrong on Red: Report on School Bus Traffic Light Violations.” (To be clear, the report targets school buses running red lights at intersections, not other vehicles running the red lights on school buses.)

The Office of the Attorney General collected and analyzed data from 15 randomly selected school bus companies operating in New York’s Westchester and Suffolk counties. The investigation found that the surveyed companies in Suffolk County received 422 red light camera tickets in 2016, while the Westchester County companies received 296.

According to the report, some school bus drivers from those companies were caught on camera running red lights on more than one occasion in 2016. From the surveyed companies, 28 of the school bus drivers in Suffolk County and 20 of those in Westchester County were hit with more than one red light camera ticket while driving bus company vehicles.

In a press release issued with the release of the report on Tuesday, Schneiderman said that state law doesn’t require traffic camera citations to be reported to the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) as part of the state’s oversight of school bus operators.

“Bus companies can rack up red light camera violations — yet have no legal obligation to report them to the state, or even use them as part of their evaluation of drivers,” the attorney general said. “It’s time for action to protect our kids by requiring bus companies to report red light violations to the state and the school districts they serve, and to use those violations in driver evaluations. We must crack down on the problem now, before it turns tragic.”

The New York Association for Pupil Transportation (NYAPT) issued a statement saying that the association “is deeply concerned about the findings” of the attorney general’s report.

“The investigative work that the attorney general has completed has revealed an area in which we can and should collaborate to improve the overall situation,” NYAPT said. “First and foremost, it is critical that all of us in school transportation deliver a clear and direct message to all of our school bus drivers about the importance of obeying the traffic signals they encounter on a daily basis.”

In its own statement, the New York School Bus Contractors Association (NYSBCA) noted that transportation providers take corrective action when a school bus driver is caught running a red light.

“In any of these instances where a driver is found to have gone through a stop light, it is not just swept under the rug — it is taken very seriously,” NYSBCA spokesman Al Roney said. “While different companies may have different disciplinary procedures, the driver is subjected to retraining, suspension, and/or possible termination.”

Both associations also highlighted the safety performance of school buses in general.

“We remind all the parents and school leaders in our state to recognize the overall outstanding safety record of New York’s school transportation operators — school district operators as well as private contractors,” NYAPT said.

“School buses are, by far … the safest mode of transportation for students to get back and forth to school each day,” Roney of NYSBCA said.

NYAPT and NYSBCA each said that they will work with the attorney general and other state officials to address the traffic light violation topic.

For his part, Schneiderman is proposing several changes in state law, including requiring school bus companies to report their number of red light camera violations to the New York Department of Motor Vehicles and to the school districts they serve. The attorney general is also recommending that any school bus drivers who accumulate three red light camera violations be disqualified from driving for one year.

Meanwhile, some legislators and members of the public are advocating the removal of red light cameras. As Newsday reported last month, an effort is underway to shut down Suffolk County’s red light camera program, which collects $31 million annually. Opponents claim that the program is designed to generate revenue rather than increase safety.

Related Topics: law enforcement, New York

Thomas McMahon Executive Editor
Comments ( 1 )
  • Annie

     | about 2 years ago

    My question is.... are they being ticketed for a red light that a school bus could not stop at when factoring in the total stopping distance equation? Is that bus got a full load that then lengthens the total stopping distance?

More Stories
Erik Richard Bonde, mayor of Rice, Minnesota, was about to pick up students when police arrived to let him know his driver’s license was suspended. His blood alcohol test results were above the legal limit for driving, police said. Photo courtesy Benton County Sheriff's Office

Minnesota Mayor Driving School Bus Charged With DUI

Erik Richard Bonde is about to pick up students when police arrive to let him know his driver’s license is suspended. His blood alcohol test results are above the legal limit for driving, police say.


School Bus Driver to be Cited in Crash With Truck

The New Jersey driver reportedly tries to make a left turn and collides with a tractor-trailer, authorities say. Fourteen students are taken to the hospital with non-life-threatening injuries.

New technology can play a role in ehancing safety, and several items on display at the NAPT trade show were created to help prevent fatal school bus crashes. File photo

Tech Advancements Offer Hope Amid Student Tragedies

It is essential that the motorists who share the road with bus drivers stop for stopped school buses. However, it is encouraging to see how technology is evolving to help provide an even safer ride for all students.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!