New York districts challenge mandated laws, regulations

Posted on April 18, 2011

Faced with the threat of layoffs, program cuts and a state budget that reduces education aid by nearly $1.3 billion, officials at school districts around New York State are challenging mandated laws and regulations that they find burdensome, costly or unnecessary. 

As an example, Port Washington Union Free School District sends out 17 buses with 1,122 seats to accommodate students from one of the district’s high schools who are eligible for bus service, even though more than half of the seats go empty at the end of the day because students stay late for sports and clubs, or find their own way home. The school district says it is required to provide a seat for every eligible child every day to comply with longstanding state laws that govern school transportation.

“It’s ludicrous to be doing this, and you can’t get anyone to listen,” Geoffrey N. Gordon, the district’s superintendent, told The New York Times. He estimated that the practice of running more buses than needed costs the district $2 million a year.

Some superintendents have also questioned a law that requires districts to provide busing and other aid to local children attending private schools as a benefit to those taxpayers.

Peter Mannella, executive director of the New York Association for Pupil Transportation, acknowledged the expense of busing private school students. He suggested limiting busing to private schools within 10 miles of a district, instead of the current 15-mile mandate, a move he said could save districts nearly $70 million a year, according to The New York Times.

Moreover, to illustrate how the mandates end up costing a lot of money, seven districts in two counties compiled a spreadsheet showing that to comply with state and federal mandates they spend a combined $94.5 million annually, or an average of 21 percent of their budgets. That amount does not include pension and healthcare increases passed along by the state.

In response to officials’ complaints over the imposed costs, Gov. Andrew Cuomo convened a statewide mandate-relief committee, and the Board of Regents has identified laws it considers outdated.

Related Topics: budget cuts, New York

Comments ( 0 )
More Stories

Mother Gets Probation for Assaulting School Bus Driver

Kiesha Shannon of Ohio pleads guilty to attacking her daughter’s bus driver and is sentenced to three years of probation. The judge says he had limited sentencing options, which is why he didn’t give her jail time.


Portable Child Restraint

HSM Transportation Solutions’ C.E. White Portable Child Restraint for school buses, a five-point restraint system, is designed to accommodate children weighing 20 to 90 pounds and up to 57 inches in height.


2-Camera System

The DS2 is a two-camera vehicle event recording system that combines high-definition video recording, fleet telematics, and vehicle operating data on one screen for better incident review and driver coaching.

As Maryland’s new state director of pupil transportation, Gabriel Rose (seen here) replaces Leon Langley, who stepped down from the position in July.

New State Director Named in Maryland

Gabriel Rose, who previously served as a security specialist for Talbot County (Md.) Public Schools, replaces Leon Langley as state director.

According to new research from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, drivers who miss one to two hours of the recommended seven hours of sleep nearly double their risk for a crash.

Don't Skimp on Safety Sleep

According to new research from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, drivers who miss one to two hours of the recommended seven hours of sleep nearly double their risk for a crash.

In the wake of the Nov. 21 fatal crash in Chattanooga, Tennessee, state lawmakers have introduced several bills that take aim at school bus safety. Photo courtesy Chattanooga Fire Department

Tennessee Legislators Target School Bus Safety

One bill would require seat belts on school buses in Tennessee. Other proposals aim to raise the state’s minimum age for school bus drivers and increase oversight of pupil transportation.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!