Contracting on the rise?
The Mackinac Center for Public Policy's 2011 school privatization survey found that 12.2 percent of districts in Michigan use privatized bus service, which is nearly triple the 2006 rate of 4.4 percent.
It’s no secret that the nation’s school districts are struggling financially, and when cuts have to be made, transportation is often a target.
In Illinois, for instance, Gov. Pat Quinn made an $89 million cut to school transportation reimbursements for fiscal year 2012. State legislators had an opportunity to restore the funds in the General Assembly’s extended veto session in late November, but they failed to do so.
At School District 54 in Schaumburg, Ill., as an example, the state cut means a loss of $1.4 million in revenue for the district.
In California, Gov. Jerry Brown announced in mid-December that funding for free school bus service would be eliminated, to the tune of $248 million.
The move came despite the objections of the California Association of School Transportation Officials and other groups, which argued that the cuts would be detrimental to students and families and would hit rural districts disproportionately hard.
So how do school districts continue busing their students when funding is slashed? Some find ways to make their transportation system more efficient. Brevard Public Schools in Cocoa, Fla., was able to save $1.2 million by changing its bell times. The district added 15 minutes between elementary and secondary bell times, which allowed for the number of bus routes to be reduced from 428 to 404.
Some school districts outsource their bus service as a way to save money. And in tough economic times like these, it seems likely that more districts would be looking to that option.
Each year, SBF collects state-by-state school transportation data, which breaks down most states’ school buses by how many are owned by districts, how many are owned by contractors and how many are owned by the state.
With those data, we can get an estimate of the proportion of school buses in the nation that are contractor owned and compare it to previous years.
In our most recent data, for the 2009-10 school year, 28.1 percent of school buses were contractor owned (that’s out of all of the school buses that states categorized as district, contractor or state owned).
In our data for the previous school year, the contractor proportion was 26.9 percent. And the year before that, it was 25.6 percent.
So there does appear to be a small but steady increase in the outsourcing of school busing. A recent report by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy showed this to be the case in Michigan.
The center’s 2011 school privatization survey found that 12.2 percent of districts in Michigan use privatized bus service, which is nearly triple the 2006 rate of 4.4 percent.
The Mackinac Center noted that the Woodhaven-Brownstown School District was expecting to save $331,200 in the first year by contracting its busing.
Still, the topic of contracting can be a contentious one in the pupil transportation community. Bus driver unions in particular have often fought tooth and nail against outsourcing.
Contracting out transportation services might not be the best solution for all school districts, but it’s an option that should at least be given serious consideration.
More Management

Have School Districts Adapted to Bus Driver Shortages or Simply Accepted Less Service?
According to a recent report from HopSkipDrive, many districts appear to have recalibrated what "normal" transportation service looks like.
Read More →
Reliable Transportation Linked to Better Student Outcomes, New EverDriven Study Finds
See why new research suggests transportation consistency improves student outcomes while influencing attendance, funding, IEP compliance, and family trust.
Read More →
Switzer-CARTY Enters the U.S. with New Acquisition
The Canadian contractor’s acquisition of Minnesota-based Agnes Corporation marks its first cross-border expansion into the United States and adds 350 vehicles.
Read More →BusRight Adds New Rider Tracking Technology
Safety Pass is an NFC-based student ridership tracking solution that provides real-time boarding and drop-off data to improve school bus safety and family communication.
Read More →
EverDriven Launches RideAware App With Real-Time Student Ride Visibility
The updated platform’s new features improve communication among caregivers, districts, and drivers while streamlining trip updates.
Read More →
How School Transportation Departments Can Help Acclimate New Riders to the Bus
Here's how transportation departments can turn first-day jitters into confidence for students and parents alike.
Read More →
Neighbors Helping Neighbors: Nearly 90 Years of Safely Transporting Wisconsin Students
From one farmer's act of service to a fourth-generation family business, Kobussen Buses reflects on nearly 90 years of earning the trust of Wisconsin families.
Read More →
Changing Lanes: AMF Bruns, Pro-Vision, CALSTART, HopSkipDrive, & Kooner
Check out who's been hired, promoted, and appointed to leadership positions at various school transportation industry suppliers and nonprofits.
Read More →
NCST Announces 18th Congress Event Dates, New Committees
The National Congress on School Transportation moves to St. Louis in May 2029, convening delegates and industry representatives to discuss new best practice recommendations. Now, the new committee chairs have been named.
Read More →
Key Moments from the 2026 NSTA Annual Meeting in the Mile High City
From federal policy updates and OEM presentations to speed networking and industry awards, see photos and highlights from the contractor association’s summer conference in Denver.
Read More →
