The trouble with cutting bus service

Thomas McMahon
Posted on May 19, 2014
Thomas McMahon is executive editor of SCHOOL BUS FLEET.

Thomas McMahon is executive editor of SCHOOL BUS FLEET.

In Etiwanda, Calif., cutting school bus service caused what one parent described as “chaotic traffic conditions” around two schools, Etiwanda Colony Elementary and Summit Intermediate.

The Etiwanda School District discontinued regular-education bus service in the 2010-11 school year because of budgetary issues.

On Dec. 4 of last year, 9-year-old Ashlyn Gardner and her 7-year-old brother Landon were crossing a street near Etiwanda Colony Elementary when they were struck by a pickup truck. Ashlyn was killed.

After the accident, local parents started two online petitions calling for the return of school bus service.

“Taking away the buses has resulted in chaotic traffic conditions daily at Colony and Summit schools,” Tressy Capps’ petition at says. “Our kids’ safety must come first!”

As of late March, a combined total of more than 1,300 people had signed the petitions.

Traffic, safety issues
In my editorial from our April/May issue, I discussed the notion that districts have a responsibility to be “in the transportation business,” which some disagree with. Here, I want to draw attention to issues that arise when districts decide to cut school bus service.

As shown in the Etiwanda example, increased traffic around schools is one of the key problems. In situations like this, long lines of vehicles often build up in the morning and afternoon. Students who walk or bike from home — and students whose parents drop them off a distance from the school — have to navigate more traffic, and therefore more risk.

Cutting bus service also deprives students of the safest way to get to school. As federal statistics show, even riding with a parent is not as safe as the yellow bus.

Another problem with cutting school bus service: Parents will fight it. That became clear in Etiwanda. Another example was at Hoover (Ala.) City Schools, where the board decided last summer to stop regular-ed transportation with the 2014-15 school year. However, many parents, students and other community members fervently protested, and the board later rescinded its decision to cut bus service.

Bring back the buses
At Etiwanda School District, about a month after the accident that killed Ashlyn Gardner and spurred the parent petitions, the board decided to bring regular-ed transportation back — to an extent. The board opted to implement a pilot transportation program for students who live at least 3 miles from their elementary or middle school of residence.

In the program, parents pay $40 per month per student, with the district contributing the remaining cost. (Special-ed transportation service is still provided free of charge.)

The pilot program was scheduled to run from March 25 to May 22. Etiwanda Superintendent Shawn Judson said in a letter to parents that the initiative offers “several positive outcomes” for the district.

“It allows the district to use excess seats for regular-education students on some current special-education bus routes and to recover revenue for those seats,” Judson said. “The program also has the potential to reduce congestion around these schools.”

At the end of this school year, the board of trustees will evaluate the feasibility of continuing the program in 2014-15.

The pilot program idea didn’t appear to appease some parents, but perhaps everyone can agree that limited bus service is better than no bus service.

Thomas McMahon Executive Editor
Comments ( 12 )
  • See all comments
  • Pete

     | about 3 years ago

    I do have to agree with the fact that the parents do act irresponsibly in the loading and unloading zones. But let one bus driver do something irresponsible and all hell brakes loose. It's about time the media starts looking at what is going on in and around the schools. And telling the truth without blowing things out of proportion.

More Stories

VIDEO: Louisiana District Rolls Out Propane Buses

Public television program MotorWeek spotlights East Baton Rouge Parish Schools, which bought 10 propane school buses after flooding wiped out a portion of its fleet last year. Now, the district has ordered 30 more.


Truck Strikes 3 Students at School Bus Stop

According to police in Minnesota, initial reports indicate that the bus was stopped with its stop arm extended, and the teens were hit by the pickup truck as they walked toward the bus.

On Dec. 1, Baltimore County Public Schools unveiled what it calls its Mobile Innovation Lab, a mobile classroom and “makerspace” built on a school bus.

PHOTOS: Baltimore District's Mobile 'Makerspace' Conversion

Baltimore County Public Schools recently unveiled its Mobile Innovation Lab, a mobile classroom and “makerspace” built on a school bus. The lab helps students learn about coding, programming, robotics, and circuitry in a hands-on environment.


Heavy-Duty Alternators

Two new families of Leece-Neville heavy-duty alternators have been designed to improve school bus electrical performance: the IdlePro and IdlePro Extreme high-efficiency/high-output alternators.

A new committee will address the development and deployment of automated vehicles and the DOT’s related research and regulations. Seen here is a Google self-driving car prototype.

DOT Forms Committee on Automation

The committee will address the development and deployment of automated vehicles and the Department of Transportation’s related research and regulations.


When the Going Gets Tough, Reitano Gets Tougher

Whether it’s solving school bus challenges, confronting a state association crisis, or fighting cancer (twice), New Jersey’s Ingrid Reitano has stayed strong for more than 40 years in pupil transportation.


Push-to-Talk Device

DispatchPlus Push-to-Talk is designed to provide one-touch communication and GPS tracking in one solution.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!