The news program cites School Bus Fleet data on driver shortage and interviews Thomas McMahon on the topic.
As the pupil transportation industry contends with the tough economic conditions, many school bus contractors are facing the same challenges, including school bus driver shortages. SCHOOL BUS FLEET’s 2012 Contractor Survey found that 83% of respondents reported some degree of shortage.
In speaking with executives at several school bus companies this year, SBF Managing Editor Kelly Roher learned that this continues to be an issue for some, and others predict that the shortage will continue as the economy recovers. The officials discuss efforts in place at their operations to help retain school bus drivers, and they shed light on other issues impacting their business, including the healthcare reform legislation.
SBF: What are you seeing in your areas of service in terms of school bus driver shortage? Are there any initiatives in place at your operation that you feel have helped to retain bus drivers?
JOHN BENISH: We started to see some minor shortages of drivers this fall. We have been especially hit hard with “underemployed drivers” who began to get back to the kind of jobs they left when the recession started. It is obvious trucking has taken off again, and this has also been tough on getting enough people in the driver seats of school buses. The initiatives we think have helped us quite a bit with retaining drivers are to make sure the current staff is happy and healthy. We feel emphasizing personnel health has been very important. Running contests for perfect attendance during the winter months has also helped us.
LINDA BURTWISTLE: We have seen pockets of driver shortage throughout North America. Over the last two years, we have worked to enhance our driver training programs to ensure that each driver feels confident and equipped to handle any situation that may arise. This builds confidence and improves morale. In addition, we are focused on employee welfare and empowerment — providing recognition, leadership opportunities and wellness initiatives across the organization.
JOHN CORRADO: The driver market has not been an issue for us over the last couple of years. I do, however, predict, as the economy recovers, we will see another significant shortage of drivers. This is still a part-time job, and attracting and keeping drivers with the typical weekly wage in our industry will be a big challenge by 2015 at the latest.
PATRICK DEAN: Our success in retaining employees starts with our personal interest in making them successful at their job. We spend many hours ensuring that new drivers and monitors understand our mission and their role in that mission before sending them out on the road.
Nearly two years ago, we implemented a school transportation applicant assessment test to help guide our staff in hiring individuals. This tool, along with our focus on the individual, has reduced turnover and increased the overall success of our identification of drivers and attendants who enjoy and succeed in their positions.
DAVID DUKE: We are seeing bus driver shortages in different parts of the U.S. and Canada. Importantly, the qualities of the person we want to recruit, hire and retain are the same that make them desirable to other employers. So as the economy improves, drivers looking for full-time work are moving to other industries and positions. To counter this, we continue to create and offer employee-centric programs to engage employees, increase self-esteem and morale, and contribute to their overall well-being. Our goal is to engage employees at every level, assuring them that they are a valued member of the organization and that their growth, development and satisfaction is important to us. A few initiatives being implemented are “listen and learn” employee focus groups that allow them to speak openly about any concerns they have, Employee of the Month, the Master Driver program, the Going the Extra Mile program, School Bus Slim Down and other proprietary programs.
DOMENIC GATTO: We do not experience school bus driver shortage in our New York City operations as a result of well-paid full-time driver positions with attractive benefits. We do experience pockets of shortage in some areas. We continually recruit and train driver applicants and provide incentives to retain them.
PATRICK VAUGHAN: As of this date, we have been fortunate to have limited shortages across North America. We credit our low turnover rate to our very experienced management team that recognizes the importance of creating a caring culture, and more importantly, a workplace environment that is focused on being responsive to our employees’ issues.Do you anticipate seeing more school districts contracting out their bus service this year?
CORRADO: I do not see a big push to contract services out, but the New York School Bus Contractors Association is supporting legislation that would allow districts that save money through outsourcing to keep those savings in their budgets for up to five years. This could help if it passes. I truly hope that districts begin to consider using the private industry when they see fit. There are safety resources that we bring to the table and certain operating efficiencies that they could take advantage of.
DEAN: We continue to see interest in contracting for student transportation for both equipment and labor needs. Throughout the Midwest, schools continue to struggle with the need for new equipment. As a contractor, we are supplementing the needs of districts by providing extra trips and routes that cannot be covered due to labor or fleet shortages. We expect these types of hybrid relationships to continue to rise in the coming years.
The decline in school finances has also increased interest in evaluating contracted transportation services. In Michigan, Gov. Rick Snyder has appropriated money for school districts that meet certain “best practices,” including investigating contracted school transportation services. School districts in Michigan have used this tool to evaluate their current transportation department and establish market benchmarks against a third-party service. In this analysis process, many schools have chosen to contract for transportation services in Michigan, while others have used these bids to reshape their district-run department.
DUKE: We’ve seen an ongoing increase in the number of districts going out to bid for transportation services. Over a three-year period, the number of bids our organization engaged grew 16%, and the number of states with conversion activity grew within a two-year period from 14 to 21 states. The triggers to motivate districts have been consistent: financial, operational and the desire for administrators to spend less time on transportation issues.
How has the Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act (aka “Obama Care”) impacted your operation, or how do you expect it will impact your operation?
CORRADO: Most operators offer some type of health insurance coverage. However, due to the part-time nature of the job and the part-time wage levels, many drivers who need insurance do not take it if they have to make a weekly contribution. My guess is that this amounts to approximately 30% of our drivers. Once we are paying for health insurance for this group in 2014, we will need a 4% to 5% increase in our pricing to cover this cost increase.
GATTO: “Obama Care” will increase our costs. We have contracts that have prices locked in for several years, such that we are starting to request reopeners on most of our school district contracts and driver union contracts to address the impact of [the] costs of Obama Care. In the long run, the costs will be passed along to taxpayers through higher bus prices.
VAUGHAN: Alongside new regulations and initiatives in the healthcare industry, Student Transportation of America is in the process of rolling out several health and wellness initiatives across the company. While we cannot control what regulations go in effect, we can help our staff with access to more health resources on and off the job. We anticipate the benefits to our company and employees being reduced absenteeism, reduced healthcare costs, and it promotes healthier lifestyles.Are there any regulatory issues at the state or national levels that you’re monitoring?
BURTWISTLE: We are constantly monitoring regulatory issues across North America. In Illinois, the change from being a low-bid state will allow decisions to be made with a variety of factors in mind, benefitting both districts and providers. In eastern Canada, the shift to an RFP process changes the way bids are submitted and accepted. In several states, a change in summer unemployment status has impacted our drivers.
CORRADO: We are concerned about pending legislation in New York that would require all bus operators to retrofit every bus with a driver interlock system connected to a Breathalyzer. This is a direct result of three school bus driver DWI arrests on Long Island last fall. I believe this would be a terrible way to address this very real concern. There are several other steps that should be taken first before we are required to install interlocks on the buses.
DEAN: In response to several tragic accidents, our legislators and industry professionals are working to determine if safety bars should be required on Michigan school buses to prevent cars from sliding under the rear bumper.
Likewise, the Michigan Legislature is again reviewing school bus stop laws which currently allow school buses to utilize hazard lights as an alternative to a traditional red light stop in certain pickup and drop-off situations.
DUKE: Some of the regulatory issues we are currently monitoring include the elimination of unemployment compensation in certain states and “Obama Care.”
What are the biggest changes you’ve seen in the industry over the past several years that have impacted the contractor market?
BENISH: The biggest changes we have seen in the school transportation industry the last couple of years are the necessity of technology on school buses, and the responsibility of reporting this information correctly and quickly to our customers — digital cameras, GPS, and now we are seeing some districts asking for wireless Internet on our buses.
BURTWISTLE: Contractor consolidation is a change that we’ve seen over the last few years, which provides the customer with greater efficiency and greater economies of scale when it comes to overall purchasing power.
DUKE: Technology is impacting the operating environment more than ever. There was a time when GPS was “nice to have,” but it is quickly becoming an essential operating tool, helping us in managing on-time performance, vehicle idling and maintenance. Fuel prices are typically volatile, but we’ve seen a consistent climb in prices over the last several years.
GATTO: Over the past several years, the school transportation industry has been experiencing stagnation brought about by the prevailing economic conditions. We have seen school districts reduce daily routes, field trips, charters and eliminate bus service due to their financial stress. The high fuel prices of recent years made matters worse.
The news program cites School Bus Fleet data on driver shortage and interviews Thomas McMahon on the topic.
Blake Krapf begins a two-year term as president of the school bus contractors association. Meanwhile, Tiffany Boykin is named the new executive director.
Two school boards work to prevent another driver shortage this fall after an investigation finds that their “actions and inactions” led to thousands of students being stranded last September.
A Durham tour in Iowa and a Calhoun County open house in Alabama are great examples of public awareness initiatives that promote the value of pupil transportation.
The nationwide tour uses interactive activities to teach safe school bus riding basics to elementary school students and their parents.
Two initiatives that the National School Transportation Association has worked extensively to modify or defeat over the past few years have recently been withdrawn by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.
Muncie Community Schools canceled the first two days of school due to transportation delays, no-show buses, and incorrect routes.
As the school year starts, the Hawaii State Department of Education temporarily consolidates and suspends routes for four schools on Maui due to a shortage of qualified drivers.
Starting in August, the contractor will provide 18 buses to transport Palisades Charter High School students.
All four of the state’s school bus drivers who advanced to the international competition placed in the top 10 in their categories.
NSTA says that after having been on the defense for many years due to continued regulatory burdens placed on the industry, a new bill takes an offensive step forward.
Winners of the association’s 2017 honors include Barry Stock of Landmark Student Transportation, Kyle Martin of TransPar, and Manuel Vasquez of First Student.
The president of Suffolk Transportation Service in New York wins School Bus Fleet’s annual honor for exemplary private operators.
The school bus company will transport more than 100 students for Salem School District starting with the 2017-18 school year.
David Mansfield of Minnesota, Billy Wiseman of West Virginia, and Hannah Beard of Missouri place first in the competition’s three school bus categories.