Safety

State Directors Delve Into Bus Crash Details

Thomas McMahon
Posted on January 15, 2010
Harold Dennis, a survivor of the fiery Carrollton, Ky., bus crash in 1988, gave a stirring presentation to NASDPTS members. Behind Dennis is an image of Larry Mahoney, the drunken driver who collided head-on with the bus.
Harold Dennis, a survivor of the fiery Carrollton, Ky., bus crash in 1988, gave a stirring presentation to NASDPTS members. Behind Dennis is an image of Larry Mahoney, the drunken driver who collided head-on with the bus.

Harold Dennis almost couldn’t go on the church trip to an amusement park. If he hadn’t, he would have missed one of the worst bus crashes in U.S. history.

But despite his single mom’s financial troubles, Dennis ended up being able to go to Kings Island with his friends that day in 1988. On the way home, their church bus — a former school bus that was built just before the 1977 safety standards began — was struck head-on by a drunken driver near Carrollton, Ky.

The fiery crash killed 27 people. Dennis was able to escape, though he was left badly burned.

At the annual conference of the National Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services (NASDPTS) in Louisville, Ky., in late October and early November, Dennis shared the details of the crash, the effects it had on enhancing bus safety and on drunken-driving laws, and how he was able to persevere and become a star athlete.

Safety improvements in the wake of the Carrollton crash included a concentrated effort in most states to phase out all pre-1977 buses, the upgrade of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) 301 — related to fuel tank integrity — and the revision of FMVSS 217 to require that the total area of emergency exits be based on the designated seating capacity.

Dennis described the tribulations he endured after the crash. Among the children who lost their lives was his best friend, Andy. Dennis told NASDPTS attendees that he went through survivor guilt. And he spent two months in the hospital being treated for his wounds, undergoing skin grafts and other painful treatments. Yet Dennis found the strength to move past the tragedy and attain success.

“I had to grow up at an early age — become a man at age 14,” he recalled. “I didn’t do it alone, and it wasn’t easy.”
Although he didn’t make the soccer team his freshman year of high school, he went on to become an all-state player and was recruited by the University of Louisville. After a year, he transferred to the University of Kentucky, where he walked on to the football team and then earned a full scholarship.

[IMAGE]447[/IMAGE]

Also at the NASDPTS conference, Minnesota state director Lt. Ed Carroll and Denny Coughlin of Minneapolis Public Schools gave a presentation on the fatal 2008 school bus crash in Cottonwood, Minn. They revealed some enlightening insights about that accident, in which four children were killed.

For example, it’s believed that a number of the bus passengers had shifted to one side of the bus to look at a passing train, which would have positioned them away from the point of impact of a pickup truck. After the bus was broadsided by a van, it began to tip and was struck by the truck in the side windows — one of the most vulnerable spots on a bus, Carroll and Coughlin said. The truck intruded into the bus almost to the center aisle.

Carroll and Coughlin emphasized the need for counseling and debriefing after severe crashes. They also noted that the bus driver, who was praised for his quick reaction in getting his students out of the bus, is still driving today.

The NASDPTS event also covered myriad changing federal and state regulations, and Barbara Duffield, policy director at the National Association for the Education of Homeless Children and Youth, discussed mandates on transporting homeless students.

During regional updates, directors shared innovative programs that have been implemented in their states, but they also noted the toll that budget cuts have taken on their pupil transportation systems.

One positive note during the session was the breaking news that Michigan had just reinstated the funding for its state school bus inspection program, which had been slated to be cut.    

Related Topics: budget cuts, NASDPTS, school bus crash

Thomas McMahon Executive Editor
Comments ( 2 )
  • See all comments
  • vilma ines kovacs

     | about 7 years ago

    Escribo desde Argentina-buenos Aires ,Mar del Plata .Me gustaría tener información de los avances que tienen Uds. en materia de seguridad en el transporte de escolares.Desde ya michas gracias

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!