Alternative Fuels

Exhaust Studies:Just Hot Air?

Posted on March 1, 2002

In the span of a week, the results of two major studies on school bus emissions were released and drew national attention. Both the Union of Concerned Scientists’ (UCS) “Pollution Report Card” and Yale professor Dr. James Wargo’s report challenged the safety of school bus fumes. Charlie Gauthier, executive director of the National Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services (NASDPTS), has become a central figure in this debate after appearing on ABC’s “Good Morning America” to talk about the studies. He discussed with SBF PLUS the position of NASDPTS on this issue. SBF Plus: What is your take on these two recent emissions studies? Gauthier: In the last year, we’ve had four studies published on diesel school buses and the potential health effects on children. We had the one by the NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council) that got this whole thing going. A couple of months later, a new one was done in Fairfax County, Va. Their conclusion was that diesel-powered school buses do not pose a health risk to students riding the bus. Then we had Dr. Wargo’s study. He concluded that in some instances children were exposed to five to 10 times dirtier air on the school bus. So after the UCS study, we still have people saying there is and people saying there isn’t a problem. I think we need to have a peer review by scientists who know what they are looking at and understand the data to find out if there really is a problem with diesel emissions. SBF Plus: How are the state directors reacting to these studies? Gauthier: Everybody feels the same way about it. You really don’t know who or what to believe. These studies were conducted by qualified organizations and individuals who seemed to follow approved or appropriate protocols. Yet, they each came up with very different conclusions. SBF Plus: What kinds of questions are the media asking you about this? Gauthier: They are all asking the same thing, which is: What should parents be thinking when they hear these reports? My standard response to them is that we have conflicting information from environmental health people. Common sense and good science says we have to figure out who’s right and who’s wrong before we go out and start scaring the public. SBF Plus: Is the media coverage fair and balanced on each side? Gauthier: I don’t know. I don’t think those are the right questions to ask right now. I think it’s good that the media is even asking us and airing our side. I’m not faulting them for ignoring us. Ideally, you would like more time to explain a bit more about your views, but at least our number one concern has been introduced and is sufficient to raise doubt about which side is correct. SBF Plus: Will this lead to major changes in school transportation? Gauthier: I really don’t know for sure at this time. For more information, go to

Comments ( 0 )
More Stories

VIDEO: Louisiana District Rolls Out Propane Buses

Public television program MotorWeek spotlights East Baton Rouge Parish Schools, which bought 10 propane school buses after flooding wiped out a portion of its fleet last year. Now, the district has ordered 30 more.


Heavy-Duty Alternators

Two new families of Leece-Neville heavy-duty alternators have been designed to improve school bus electrical performance: the IdlePro and IdlePro Extreme high-efficiency/high-output alternators.

An article about school districts’ successes with stop-arm cameras was the most-viewed feature on the SBF website this year.

Top 5 Most-Viewed Feature Articles of 2016

Feature articles that drew the most traffic on the School Bus Fleet website in 2016 covered stop-arm cameras, electric school buses, and student behavior management, among other topics.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!