Is safety compromised by the driver shortage?

Steve Hirano, Editor
Posted on February 1, 1998

The mounting shortage of school bus drivers is like a distant siren gaining in volume and arousal, signaling the imminent arrival of an emergency. Steps need to be taken now to prevent the emergency from becoming a full-blown disaster. Our 1998 survey of state directors of pupil transportation indicates that the driver shortage is a "moderate" to "serious" problem in the vast majority of states. In some states, the shortage is described as "desperate." Only one state said it had no driver shortage. As we all know, the driver shortage has been a problem for decades, but this latest crunch has been intensified by record low unemployment. There is nothing that can be done about the unemployment situation (it's a good thing for most of America), but it puts a terrible burden on school districts that compete for drivers on the basis of wages and hours. Lower standards, higher risks
Everyone in the pupil transportation industry should be looking long and hard at the shortage's possible impact on school bus safety. Let's face it, school bus operators who are hurting for drivers are more likely to accept less-than-satisfactory candidates. I've heard that drivers with questionable backgrounds are being hired by desperate school bus operators. In some cases, poor driving records and criminal backgrounds are being overlooked. That's simply unacceptable. Not only do these situations create enormous liability exposure for the school bus operator, they also compromise the safety of the passengers. The best way to avoid a potential disaster with questionable drivers is not to hire them in the first place. That requires discipline and extraordinary effort in hiring top-notch candidates and retaining your veteran drivers. What can be done? Lots of things. In his first major piece for SBF, Senior Editor Dale MacDiarmid offers sound strategies collected from school transportation professionals around the country. Don't just read this article, clip it and refer to it when you think you've exhausted every avenue of driver recruitment. Build their self-esteem
I have another suggestion. It has nothing to do with classified advertising or word-of-mouth campaigns or finder's fees. It won't bring instant results. It won't even sound good when voiced at a school board meeting. My idea involves self-esteem. I believe drivers want — and need — to be treated like professionals. We all know how difficult their jobs are. Oh, they may whine incessantly about their wages or their "ancient" bus or the behavior of the children, but they are handling one of the most difficult assignments in the field of education. My point is that they deserve respect — from transportation managers, principals, parents and the public in general. That's why I was heartened to learn of the growing popularity of special-needs roadeos (See "How to Organize a Special-Needs Roadeo.") This type of event — like its regular-education counterpart — lets drivers (and attendants) know that they're worthy of special attention. It boosts their confidence and improves morale. We need to show drivers that they're special. Another strong display of respect for drivers can be seen in the ergonomic improvements in school buses at Boston Public Schools (see "Boston's Ergonomic Revolution.") Transportation Director Rich Jacobs says the extra money spent on air-ride seats, power doors and softer suspension systems is a small price to pay for driver satisfaction. "Sometimes we need to show drivers that not only are we listening, but that we hear them," he says. Take the time to listen to your drivers. Take the time to hear them, too. This won't solve your driver shortage, but it will be a step in the right direction.

Related Topics: driver shortage

Comments ( 0 )
More Stories

VIDEO: Louisiana District Rolls Out Propane Buses

Public television program MotorWeek spotlights East Baton Rouge Parish Schools, which bought 10 propane school buses after flooding wiped out a portion of its fleet last year. Now, the district has ordered 30 more.


Truck Strikes 3 Students at School Bus Stop

According to police in Minnesota, initial reports indicate that the bus was stopped with its stop arm extended, and the teens were hit by the pickup truck as they walked toward the bus.

On Dec. 1, Baltimore County Public Schools unveiled what it calls its Mobile Innovation Lab, a mobile classroom and “makerspace” built on a school bus.

PHOTOS: Baltimore District's Mobile 'Makerspace' Conversion

Baltimore County Public Schools recently unveiled its Mobile Innovation Lab, a mobile classroom and “makerspace” built on a school bus. The lab helps students learn about coding, programming, robotics, and circuitry in a hands-on environment.


When the Going Gets Tough, Reitano Gets Tougher

Whether it’s solving school bus challenges, confronting a state association crisis, or fighting cancer (twice), New Jersey’s Ingrid Reitano has stayed strong for more than 40 years in pupil transportation.


Push-to-Talk Device

DispatchPlus Push-to-Talk is designed to provide one-touch communication and GPS tracking in one solution.


Type A School Bus

The Trans Star, Trans Tech’s new Type A school bus, is a 20-passenger, dual rear-wheel bus that features the company’s signature aerodynamic design, according to the manufacturer.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from SBF delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the school bus industry and don't miss a thing!